These councillors say Zionism is racism
Tell them
Racist

The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist. Why

"Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", Greens for Palestine, 19 February 2026

Their webinar on the “Zionism is Racism” motion, line by line

Five weeks before the party's spring conference, Greens for Palestine held a 99-minute webinar to win support for their motion, with its proposer, Lubna Speitan, and two speakers they invited: Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner and the barrister Frank McGuinness. We have listened to every minute. Here is what was said, quoted exactly from the stream with the time, and why it is wrong.

99
minutes, every one listened to
17
quotations, each with its time
0
times the chair questioned any of it

Criticising Israeli governments, the occupation or the conduct of the war in Gaza is not antisemitism, and nothing on this page says it is. Jews who oppose Zionism are as Jewish as any other Jews. What follows is about what was said of Jews, of the Holocaust, of the Jews of Israel, and about the facts.

  1. The Jews of Israel "have two choices": accept Palestinian rule or "leave". Otherwise they are "fascists", and "we know what is to be done with fascists", up to "military arms struggle". The chair called it "extremely welcome".

  2. The motion's "all available means" is "a euphemistic way of saying that the Palestinians have a right to arms struggle and that we should support it."

  3. Hamas is "that Palestinian resistance faction"; the motion should also have named the leader of the PFLP.

  4. Jewish members afraid of the motion were told they are safe if they do not support Israel, and if they do, "they can expect anti-Semitism". Others were described as raised in "a cult", in need of "deprogramming".

  5. "The Germans were not involved" in running Auschwitz, which was "done by the inmates"; most Germans "had no idea" of the Holocaust. Both are false.

  6. The Jewish people "are not a nation"; the West's politicians, capitals, elites and media are "occupied" by Zionism.

  7. "A free and liberated Palestine from the river to the sea": the proposer's own words for what the motion is for.

What was said to and about Jews

6 quotations

What they say

Jews who live in Palestine now have two choices. They can either embrace Palestinian national liberation, or they can leave. The third option is for them to embrace fascism. And we know what is to be done with fascists. We must collectively crush fascism in the political sphere, the economic sphere, the theoretical sphere, as well as in the sphere of military arms struggle.

Antisemitic

Frank McGuinness, a barrister and invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 1:02:45 to 1:03:45)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. It tells the Jews of Israel to submit or leave, or be counted as "fascists", against whom it calls for "military arms struggle".

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Calling for, aiding, or justifying the killing or harming of Jews in the name of a radical ideology or an extremist view of religion."

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

Seven million Jews live in Israel. They are given three options: accept rule by others, leave, or be counted as "fascists", about whom "we know what is to be done", up to and including "military arms struggle". That is not a debate about an ideology. It is a threat to a people, by name.

This is what "equal rights for all" in a single state looks like to a speaker the motion's authors chose. The chair's reply, a minute later: "Thank you so much, Frank, for that contribution and your analysis of the motion. It is extremely welcome."

What they say

So the question of not feeling safe, people should feel totally safe if they don't support racism. There is no threat to anyone who is not supporting the racist state of Israel and its policies. There's no threat for others as well, but they can expect anti-Semitism. ... And of course, Jews in this country should be extremely wary about supporting Israel, because doing so is actually guaranteeing the growth of anti-Semitism. ... This is the machine that produces anti-Semitism. And this is what happens when Jews are supporting in large numbers the crimes of Israel.

Antisemitic

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 1:12:05 to 1:13:13, 0:26:27 to 0:27:32, and 1:08:34 to 1:09:35)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. It tells Jews who support Israel that they "can expect anti-Semitism": Jews blamed for the hatred of Jews.

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Holding Jews collectively responsible for actions of the state of Israel."

Asked whether Jewish members were right to feel unsafe, the answer was: you are safe if you do not support Israel, and if you do, you "can expect anti-Semitism". Most British Jews say Israel is part of who they are. They are told that hatred of them is their own doing.

Blaming Jews for antisemitism is one of its oldest forms. The definition adopted by the UK Government gives "holding Jews collectively responsible for actions of the state of Israel" as an example. Nobody on the panel challenged it.

What they say

First, I want to say that the Jewish people are not a nation. They are not an ethnicity. They are a cultural and religious group that lived historically in Europe, later on in North and South America, and of course in the Arab world.

AntisemiticFactually wrong

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 1:07:26 to 1:08:33)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. It says Jews are not a nation and not an ethnicity, in answer to a question about Jewish self-determination.

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

Factually wrong. English law treats Jews as an ethnic group as well as a faith.

This was his answer to the chair's question about Jewish self-determination, and about Jewish members of the party who said the motion made them feel unsafe. The answer begins by telling Jews what they are not.

English law treats Jews as an ethnic group as well as a faith: the Supreme Court did so in the JFS case in 2009. Jews have called themselves a people for three thousand years. And his list of where Jews lived leaves out the one place their language, religion and history come from.

What they say

Self-determination is not available to settler colonials. ... And if whites want to have self-determination as whites, they can go to the West, you know? Not in South Africa, not in Algeria, and not in Palestine. ... So if they want self-determination, let them find a country which is really empty. ... So I think every Jew who is ready to live with non-Jews, in other words, with Palestinians in equality, will be welcome in Palestine, but not people who want to use their supremacy to control Palestinians. That is going to end.

Antisemitic

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 1:09:35 to 1:12:05)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. It casts Jews as "settler colonials" with no right to self-determination, to "find a country which is really empty".

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

Jews are cast as "settler colonials" with no claim to the land, told to "find a country which is really empty", and offered a place only on conditions set by others. More than half of Israel's Jews descend from Jews of the Middle East and North Africa, some 850,000 of whom were driven out of Arab countries after 1948. They had nowhere else to go.

Self-determination is a right of peoples, and the Jewish people's claim to a home in the land was recognised by the League of Nations in 1922. Denying it to Jews alone is the example the UK Government's definition of antisemitism gives.

What they say

And remember that before Zionism could occupy Palestine, it had to occupy the Jewish mind. So the Zionist occupation started with occupying the Jewish mind and the Christian mind through Christian Zionism. And now, it's occupied all politicians of the West. We can see that. It's occupied the capitals of the West, the elites of the West, the media of the West.

Antisemitic

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 1:33:16 to 1:34:22)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. It says Zionism has "occupied" the West's politicians, capitals, elites and media: the movement of most Jews as a hidden hand.

Why is this antisemitic?

Jews secretly controlling governments, police, banks or the press is the oldest antisemitic conspiracy theory there is. Putting "Zionists" or "the lobby" where the older word was does not change what it is.

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective, such as, especially but not exclusively, "the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions"."

The politicians, the capitals, the elites and the media of the West, all "occupied" by Zionism: the movement of most Jews as a hidden hand controlling governments and the press. Put "the Jews" where "Zionism" stands and it is the oldest conspiracy theory there is.

What they say

Being raised with Jewish Christian Zionism is effectively being raised in a cult. Freedom from Zionism is freedom for Jewish people too. Cult deprogramming is incredibly difficult. ... Can we include a plan, policy to show compassion and support to fellow Greens who will be struggling across the deconstruction of their brainwashing ... [Lubna Speitan:] The short of that is literally it's just taking courage. It's looking at the situation and analyzing it for what it is and having the courage to step outside of that and join us.

A question from the audience, read out by the chair, and the answer of Lubna Speitan, the motion's proposer, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 1:28:45 to 1:30:09, and 1:36:02 to 1:37:04)

What is wrong with it

Jewish members of the Green Party, described as raised in "a cult" and in need of "deprogramming" from their "brainwashing". The chair read it out. The motion's proposer did not question the premise; her answer was that they should find the courage to "join us".

This is how the motion's authors spoke about the Jewish members it affects, while campaigning for it.

Armed struggle, Hamas and the PFLP

3 quotations

What they say

Paragraph 4 talks about, quote, "the struggle to achieve that liberation by all available means under international law." That's a euphemistic way of saying that the Palestinians have a right to arms struggle and that we should support it.

Frank McGuinness, a barrister and invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:59:37 to 1:00:42)

What is wrong with it

The motion's words, read at its authors' own event by a speaker they invited: "all available means" means armed struggle, and the Green Party should back it. Nobody on the panel said otherwise.

Armed struggle against Israel is not an abstraction. On 7 October 2023 it meant the murder of some 1,200 people, most of them civilians, and the taking of 251 hostages. A party that says it seeks peace has passed a clause its own supporters read as support for that.

What they say

So in my opinion, the strategies that win subordinate any kind of legal tactics to a prior political strategy, in this case an anti-Zionist strategy that revolves around the observation that Palestine will be liberated on the battlefield in Palestine, and that our role in the diaspora is to try to lend what support we can to that Palestinian strategic choice. ... The most important thing is to proclaim our support for the Palestinian armed struggle.

Frank McGuinness, a barrister and invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:46:33 to 0:47:32, and 1:16:13)

What is wrong with it

Not boycotts, not elections, not law: "the battlefield". The most important thing for a Green Party member to do, on this account, is to proclaim support for armed attacks.

He began by saying elections should be used "to agitate for important anti-imperialist positions, such as support for the Palestinian armed struggle and the project of abolishing the apartheid state of Israel. And so this motion clearly is a contribution to that struggle." The chair thanked him for it.

What they say

And we also have the Hamas case, which is ongoing. The Islamic Resistance Movement challenges the British government's decision to prescribe that Palestinian resistance faction. ... it was perhaps a missed opportunity to also name Ahmad Sadat, also known as Abu Hassan, who is the Secretary-General of the Marxist-Leninist Party, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.

Misleading

Frank McGuinness, a barrister and invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:55:37 to 0:56:34, and 1:00:43 to 1:01:42)

What is wrong with it

Misleading. Hamas, which carried out the 7 October massacre, is proscribed in full in the UK; it is called a "resistance faction".

Hamas, which carried out the 7 October massacre and has been proscribed in full in the UK since 2021, is called a "resistance faction", and its challenge to the ban is listed among the movement's legal wins.

Ahmad Sa'adat leads the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which claimed the 2001 assassination of the Israeli minister Rehavam Ze'evi; an Israeli military court jailed him for 30 years in 2008. The PFLP is listed as a terrorist organisation by the European Union and the United States. The complaint was that the motion did not name him alongside Marwan Barghouti.

The Holocaust

3 quotations

What they say

Do you know how many people, how many Germans actually operated Auschwitz, in which 20,000 people died every day? Less than 200 SS. ... And actually, the whole operation in Auschwitz and in other camps were actually done by the inmates who did the welcome of the people who arrived, who got them into the showers, who got them to remove their clothes, and then they moved the bodies into the ovens and so on. The Germans were not involved in this.

Factually wrong

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:36:22 to 0:37:26)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Some 7,000 to 8,000 SS men served at Auschwitz; SS doctors made the selections and SS men poured the Zyklon B. "The Germans were not involved" is false.

The facts

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the fact, scope, mechanisms (e.g. gas chambers) or intentionality of the genocide of the Jewish people at the hands of National Socialist Germany and its supporters and accomplices during World War II (the Holocaust)."

This is false. Some 7,000 to 8,000 SS men served at Auschwitz over its existence, according to the Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum. SS doctors made the selections on the ramp, and SS men poured the Zyklon B into the gas chambers.

The prisoners of the Sonderkommando, most of them Jews, were forced to work at the crematoria on pain of death, and most were murdered in turn. To say "the Germans were not involved" puts the work of the gas chambers on its Jewish victims.

It was said to make a point about Israel: that the Holocaust needed few perpetrators, and that, in his next words, "The Israeli genocide is different. Hundreds of thousands of people are involved directly".

What they say

Now, we can see now that, as opposed to the Nazi genocide of Jews that was kept very secret, as you know, and a lot of Germans kept saying after the war, they had no idea about it. And actually, I think that most of them were right. They didn't have any idea about it and probably would not even have supported it because they didn't know about it.

Factually wrong

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:30:51 to 0:31:57)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. The murder of the Jews was "an open secret" in Germany: more than a million were shot in the open in the east, and deportations left German stations in daylight.

Historians have shown the opposite. The murder of the Jews was what Frank Bajohr and Dieter Pohl called "an open secret": more than a million Jews were shot in the open in the east, in front of soldiers, police and locals, and the deportations left from German railway stations in daylight.

The point was to say that Germans could be excused, and Israelis cannot: "The Nazis didn't do that. I'm not comparing," he said, and then compared.

What they say

This is the most democratic genocide that humanity has seen. ... So a very small number of Germans did an incredible number of murders. The Israeli genocide is different. Hundreds of thousands of people are involved directly, and their families are involved and voted for it in the polls, in a sense.

Antisemitic

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:33:03 to 0:34:06, and 0:36:22 to 0:37:26)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. It compares Israel with Nazi Germany and finds it worse, and holds Israelis and their families collectively guilty.

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis."

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Holding Jews collectively responsible for actions of the state of Israel."

Israel set against Nazi Germany, and found worse: the Germans a few hundred, the Israelis hundreds of thousands, and their families too. A whole people, by this account, is guilty.

The definition of antisemitism adopted by the UK Government gives "drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis" and "holding Jews collectively responsible for actions of the state of Israel" as examples.

What the proposer said

2 quotations

What they say

While the true terrorizers, those funding these war crimes and the IOF who slaughter our families and people, continue walking the streets here, amongst us, in our Olympics, in our footballs, without sanctions or accountability. ... a vote to dismantle the racist ideology of Zionism and rebuild something just in its place: a free and liberated Palestine from the river to the sea. ... It began in this country and must end in this country.

Antisemitic

Lubna Speitan, the motion's proposer, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:12:20 to 0:13:18, and 0:17:38 to 0:18:16)

What is wrong with it

Antisemitic. "From the river to the sea" is the whole land with no Israel in it, and the "true terrorizers" walking "amongst us" are Israelis and the British Jews who served in its army.

Why is this antisemitic?

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."

The IHRA working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the UK Government, gives this as an example: "Holding Jews collectively responsible for actions of the state of Israel."

From the river to the sea is the whole of the land, Israel included: the motion's own single state, in the proposer's words. And the people she calls "the true terrorizers", walking "amongst us" in Britain, at the Olympics and at football, are Israelis and the British Jews who served in Israel's army.

What they say

... as do examples of definitions like the IHRA and JDA, definitions which have been designed to silence our voices along with the voices of our advocates and Jewish allies who also oppose Israel and its continued genocide and war crimes. Designed, ultimately, to protect Israel from criticism and to shield racism.

Misleading

Lubna Speitan, the motion's proposer, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:13:19 to 0:14:26)

What is wrong with it

Misleading. The IHRA definition says in terms that criticism of Israel like that of any other country is not antisemitic.

The IHRA definition says in terms that "criticism of Israel similar to that leveled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic". The Jerusalem Declaration was written by IHRA's own critics. Both are rejected, so that the motion's authors, not Jews, decide what counts as hatred of Jews.

The history and the facts

2 quotations

What they say

Just a note about history, anti-Semitism was and remains a Western and European phenomenon. There was no anti-Semitism to speak of in the Arab and Muslim world. Jews were treated with as close to equality as was possible at all in most of the Arab world. ... That Hebrew as a language was dead until Al-Andalus. ... Indeed, in Palestine, for 2,000 years, they lived together beautifully.

Factually wrong

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 1:07:26 to 1:08:33, 1:31:11 to 1:32:13, and 1:33:16 to 1:34:22)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Jews were massacred in Granada in 1066, Safed in 1834, Hebron in 1929 and Baghdad in 1941, and some 850,000 left or were driven from Arab countries after 1948.

Jews under Muslim rule were dhimmis, protected but not equal, paying a special tax. In al-Andalus itself, the Jews of Granada were massacred in 1066, and the Almohads forced Jews to convert or flee in the 1140s; Maimonides' family fled. In Palestine, Jews were massacred in Safed in 1834 and Hebron in 1929. In Baghdad, the Farhud of 1941 killed some 180 Jews. About 850,000 Jews left or were driven from Arab countries after 1948.

Hebrew was not dead before al-Andalus: the Mishnah was written in it around 200, and Hebrew religious poetry was composed in Byzantine Palestine in the 500s and 600s.

What they say

Israel, which has committed more war crimes than any other country member of the UN, has never faced any sanctions. Iran has faced sanctions for 45 years. Cuba has faced sanctions for 60 years. These are countries that never attacked anyone. Never. ... Israel has used 12, the equivalent of 12 atomic bombs. Each of those atomic bombs killed 115,000 people.

Factually wrong

Professor Haim Bresheeth-Zabner, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:37:27 to 0:38:37, and 1:25:11 to 1:26:24)

What is wrong with it

Factually wrong. Iran fired some 300 drones and missiles at Israel in April 2024 and some 180 ballistic missiles that October; Britain sanctioned two Israeli ministers in June 2025.

Iran fired some 300 drones and missiles at Israel in April 2024 and some 180 ballistic missiles in October 2024, and arms Hezbollah and the Houthis. Cuba sent tens of thousands of troops to fight in Angola and Ethiopia.

Israel has faced sanctions: Britain sanctioned the Israeli ministers Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich in June 2025, as Frank McGuinness himself said later in the same webinar.

The bomb on Nagasaki was about 21 kilotons, not 15, and the death tolls of the two bombs were very different. Comparing the total weight of conventional explosives dropped over two years with a single nuclear blast tells you nothing about deaths.

What the chair said

1 quotation

What they say

Thank you so much, Frank, for that contribution and your analysis of the motion. It is extremely welcome.

Misleading

The chair, at Greens for Palestine's webinar "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105", 19 February 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 1:04:55)

What is wrong with it

Misleading. In 99 minutes the chair did not question a word, and called a call for "military arms struggle" against Israel's Jews "extremely welcome".

The chair's response to a talk that ended by telling the Jews of Israel to submit, leave or face "military arms struggle". In 99 minutes the chair did not question one word said by any speaker, and ended by asking members to make sure the motion was heard at conference.

Taken together

What it adds up to

The Green Party says the motion is about an ideology, not about Jews. At the motion's own campaign event, its proposer and her invited speakers told the Jews of Israel to submit or leave, called armed struggle the motion's meaning, called Hamas a resistance faction, told Jewish members they could expect antisemitism, and rewrote the Holocaust. The chair called it "extremely welcome". The motion they were campaigning for was passed, in its autumn version, by the party's conference on 4 October 2026.

Zionism is not racism. Green councillors can say so by signing the pledge; councillors and MPs of every other party, by adding their name.

Green councillors: sign the pledge Other councillors and MPs: add your name

Quotations are from an automated transcript of the stream "Zionism Is Racism: A Discussion On Motion A105" (Greens for Palestine, YouTube, 19 February 2026), with the time in the video. They are quoted for criticism and review.