The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist.Why →
"Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", Greens for Palestine, 4 August 2026
Their stream of 4 August 2026, line by line
Two months before the autumn conference, Greens for Palestine streamed a 71-minute webinar for the "Zionism is Racism" motion, then numbered A3, with its proposer, Lubna Speitan, and two speakers they invited: Dr Ghada Karmi and Dr Ramzy Baroud. The chair thanked "the Global Majority Greens for hosting". We have listened to every minute. Here is what was said, quoted exactly from the stream with the time, and why it is wrong.
71
minutes, every one listened to
12
quotations, each with its time
1
sitting Green councillor whose question was read out
0
times the chair questioned any of it
Criticising Israeli governments, the occupation or the conduct of the war in Gaza is not antisemitism, and nothing on this page says it is. Palestinians are entitled to tell their own history. What follows is about what was said of Jews and of the Jews of Israel, of armed struggle and Hamas, of synagogues, and about what the proposer says her motion means.
The proposer set out, in her own words, what the motion means: the party declared anti-Zionist, both definitions of antisemitism rejected, "a single democratic Palestinian state", the "right of all oppressed people to resist their oppressors by all available means", and Hamas and Palestine Action taken off the proscribed list.
2
An invited speaker said the founders of Israel "should never have defined themselves as Jews", called Jews "this invented race", and said Palestinians could not be asked to share a state with "killers, rapists, and descendants of rapists". The other said "we will use arms" whatever international law says. The chair thanked them both.
3
A sitting Green councillor on Newcastle City Council, named on this site as a backer of the motion, sent in a question asserting a right "to take up arms".
01
What was said of Jews and the Jews of Israel
4 quotations
What they say
Zionism is really nothing to do with Judaism. Secondly, Zionists are very little to do with Jews. ... They called themselves Jews, but they actually have no qualifications for a title like "Jews." ... they really, strictly speaking, should never have defined themselves as Jews. ... this invented race called Jews.
Dr Ghada Karmi, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:02:26 to 0:05:54)
What is wrong with it
Herzl, Weizmann and Ben-Gurion are told, a century on, that they were not Jews, and the Jewish people that they are "invented". Jews have called themselves a people for three thousand years; English law treats them as an ethnic group as well as a faith, as the Supreme Court held in the JFS case in 2009. Telling Jews who is and is not a Jew is not analysis of Zionism. It is the thing the motion's supporters say they never do.
This was the opening speech, chosen to "lay the framework of this debate", as the next speaker put it. The chair's response: "Thank you very much for that contribution ... It's very, very much appreciated."
It's very difficult to imagine that you would ask Palestinians to share their homeland with killers, rapists, and descendants of rapists. ... I'm not talking about the '67. I'm talking about the whole Israeli people who are settlers or children of settlers.
Dr Ghada Karmi, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:39:15 to 0:41:33)
What is wrong with it
Seven million Jews, "the whole Israeli people", as "killers, rapists, and descendants of rapists". This was the answer to the question of whether the motion's single state could work. It is what "equal rights for all" in that state looks like to the speaker the motion's authors chose to explain it.
Our duty is to say over and over again that Zionism is racist, that it was responsible for our eviction, and that it is evil and it has to go from this world. ... I really commend the Green Party. They're setting the pace for this.
Dr Ghada Karmi, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:09:28, and 0:53:19)
What is wrong with it
The belief that Israel should exist, held by most British Jews, is "evil" that "has to go from this world"; and the Green Party is commended for "setting the pace". Two months later the party made that belief, in its own words, "any other form of racism".
What they say
All the 80% to 90% of all Israelis who supported the genocide ... These are not a group of people that anyone can coexist with. ... The only solution is the defeat of Zionism, and everything else will be sorted out after that. ... Palestine being restored to its former self ... I would like to call that state Palestine.
Dr Ramzy Baroud, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:42:34 to 0:47:33)
What is wrong with it
The motion calls for "a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine". Its own panel explains what that means: no coexistence with the Israelis who live there, the "defeat" of their state, and its name removed from the map. That is the end of Israel, said plainly at the event held to pass the motion.
02
Armed struggle, Hamas and a sitting councillor
3 quotations
What they say
You resist by every means that you're able to. ... when you're dealing with something like the state of Israel, there is no such thing as peaceful resistance. ... Maybe I should boycott Starbucks. Maybe that's how it usually works. This is utter nonsense. ... Frankly, even if international law says plainly Palestinians have no right to use arms, we will use arms.
Dr Ghada Karmi, an invited speaker, and Dr Ramzy Baroud, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 1:00:55 to 1:02:38, and 1:02:42 to 1:04:43)
What is wrong with it
The motion's words are "all available means". Here is what its own panel takes them to mean: there is "no such thing as peaceful resistance", boycotts are "utter nonsense", and arms will be used whatever the law says. The motion's briefing paper had already spelt it out as "including armed struggle". Nobody on the panel, and not the chair, said otherwise.
What they say
I believe the Palestinian people have a legal right to resist their occupation by all means necessary including the right to take up arms as per international law. In your opinion, where does the resistance fit in with a one state solution?
A question from Cllr Chandni Chopra, Green councillor for Heaton on Newcastle City Council, shown on screen with her name and read out by the chair, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:59:39)
What is wrong with it
A sitting Green councillor, named on this site among the councillors who backed the motion, puts her name to "the right to take up arms" at the event held to pass it. The answers she received are the two quotations above: "no such thing as peaceful resistance" and "we will use arms". Her own page on this site records her words.
What they say
If you're going to label me as Hamas because I stand up and support the deprescription of a resistance, of a democratically elected government of the Palestinian people, which is their right to self-determination, then call me it. ... I will advocate to support the deprescription because, again, irrespective of what one's views are on them, this is a right. ... whether that is Hamas or Palestine Action.
Lubna Speitan, the motion's proposer, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 1:08:17 to 1:09:17)
What is wrong with it
Hamas murdered some 1,200 people on 7 October 2023 and took 251 hostages. It has been proscribed in full in the UK since November 2021. The Palestinian people last voted in 2006. The motion's proposer says she will advocate taking Hamas off the proscribed list; the motion she wrote asks the party to do so for Palestine Action. The chair thanked her for "your amazing contributions".
The first step ... is to declare the party anti-Zionist. ... the IHRA and JDA definitions of antisemitism, which goal is not to protect Jews from discrimination for being Jewish, but to protect a racist state from the criticism it so rightly deserves ... a single democratic Palestinian state, equal rights for all, and the right of return ... a right of all oppressed people to resist their oppressors by all available means. ... the release of our prisoners of conscience, including Marwan Barghouti ... the deprescription of Palestine action.
Lubna Speitan, the motion's proposer, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:27:54 to 0:30:51)
What is wrong with it
This is the motion the party passed, described by the woman who wrote it: an anti-Zionist party; both definitions of antisemitism rejected as a shield for "a racist state"; one state in place of Israel; "all available means"; Marwan Barghouti, convicted of five murders, a prisoner of conscience; and a proscribed organisation to be unbanned. Read it beside the motion, clause by clause, on the main site.
What they say
Zionism means different things to different people. Simple answer, I'm sure the same applied with the Nazis. I'm sure Nazis meant different things to different Nazis.
Lubna Speitan, the motion's proposer, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:34:20)
What is wrong with it
Jewish members had told the party that Zionism, to them, means that Israel should exist. The proposer's answer is that the Nazis also disagreed among themselves. "Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis" is an example of antisemitism in the definition her motion rejects; here the comparison is of the Jews who hold the belief.
They're literally using it as a front to commit war crimes, selling stolen land, our land, in their synagogues, which in addition to that, many of these synagogues are funding the IOF and putting their children through schools to become the next IOF settlers who come and slaughter our families, steal our homes, rape our children. ... Imagine if the mosques, for example, funded ISIS. ... we should put pressure on those spaces.
Lubna Speitan, the motion's proposer, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:36:14 to 0:37:18)
What is wrong with it
Synagogues as fronts for war crimes, their children raised to "rape our children", and a call to "put pressure on those spaces". A synagogue is where Jews pray. The Community Security Trust recorded attacks on synagogues among the 3,528 incidents of 2024. The leader of the Green Party tried to amend the motion to protect Jewish members who attend Zionist synagogues; his amendment was blocked. This is why they needed it.
We have over 700 and, what is it, 45 co-proposers now. ... It's already reached Australia. ... take this motion to your trade union branches, to other organizations and campaign groups, and send it around the world. ... please run with it. Take it into your unions, your other parties internationally.
Lubna Speitan, the motion's proposer, and Tariq Khawaja, the chair, for Greens for Palestine, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:58:18 to 0:59:19, and 1:10:18)
What is wrong with it
The motion was never meant to stay inside the Green Party. Its authors say so: unions, other parties, other countries. The party passed it on 4 October 2026, and the councillors on this site are the ones who put their names to it.
What they say
I've been thinking about Andy Burnham. ... This is a new prime minister. It's a new opportunity. And I think we need to talk to him, we Palestinians and our friends. We need to approach him, talk to him, and point him in the direction which would suggest, which would mean, and in the end, a change in UK policy.
Dr Ghada Karmi, an invited speaker, at Greens for Palestine's live stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism", 4 August 2026 (automated transcript of the stream, 0:53:19 to 0:54:34)
What is wrong with it
The Prime Minister gave his answer in the House of Commons after the vote: "Can I condemn the motion that was passed unequivocally. It is wrong. It is antisemitic, and this side of the House will have nothing to do with it."
In 1975 the United Nations General Assembly declared that "Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination". In 1991 it revoked that, by 111 votes to 25. The motion's authors brought the idea back, and at their own event for it said what they mean by it: Jews who are not Jews, a state with no room for the people who live in it, arms whatever the law says, and synagogues to be pressured.
Zionism is not racism. Green councillors can say so by signing the pledge; councillors and MPs of every other party, by adding their name.
Quotations are from an automated transcript of the stream "Palestinian Reality & The Struggle Against Zionism" (Greens for Palestine, YouTube, 4 August 2026), with the time in the video. They are quoted for criticism and review.