These councillors say Zionism is racism
Racist

The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist. Why

← All the councillors

Cllr Alexi Dimond

Said it in public

Green Party councillor

Cllr Alexi Dimond

Gleadless Valley ward, Sheffield

Reported saying: “We do recognise there is a diversity of beliefs among people who identify as Zionists, and accept that some people who identify as Zionists disagree with the ideology of political Zionism as practiced by the Israeli state and are not racist.”

Party
Green Party
Reported
3 November 2026

Tell them why it’s wrongWhy Cllr Dimond is wrongThe councillors who backed the motion

On video, 26 October 2026

Cllr Dimond on The Crispin Flintoff Show: "nobody can say that that is not racist"

On 26 October 2026 Cllr Dimond defended the motion on The Crispin Flintoff Show, with Cllr Charli Thompson of Barnet, answering Andy Burnham and Sir Ed Davey. Here is the video, what is wrong with what was said, and the transcript.

The Crispin Flintoff Show, on YouTube, 26 October 2026 (21 min 40 s). Played from YouTube in its privacy-enhanced mode, for criticism and review.

What is wrong with it

  1. At 2:21: "Well, firstly, I have to say that it's disgusting conflation of Zionism and Judaism,..."

    Neither Andy Burnham nor Sir Ed Davey said that Zionism and Judaism are the same thing. They said the motion is antisemitic: Mr Burnham that "It is wrong, it is anti-Semitic", Sir Ed that it is "a dangerous and anti-Semitic policy". Nine in ten British Jews regard Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people (Institute for Jewish Policy Research, 2010). In this campaign's view, that is why a motion declaring Zionism racism is antisemitic: it calls a belief most British Jews hold racist, whatever word is used for it.

  2. At 2:21: "But also, for Ed Davey, particularly disappointing given the support for the genocide..."

    The Board of Deputies of British Jews is elected by synagogues and Jewish community organisations across the country. It supports a two-state solution: a Palestinian state alongside Israel. Cllr Dimond gives no example of the "support for the genocide" alleged. In this campaign's view, accusing British Jews' own representative body of backing genocide is the kind of charge the motion's critics warned it would license.

  3. At 3:23: ""We passed this motion with the biggest mandate," in, I think, one of the biggest..."

    The motion passed at the Green Party conference by 1,022 votes to 813. The party has about 220,000 members, the figure the motion's proposer gave at its authors' own press conference. So 1,835 members voted, fewer than one in a hundred, and the 1,022 who voted for it are under half of one per cent of the party.

  4. At 7:58: "And the leader of Sheffield's... Sheffield Labour Party... said at a meeting that's..."

    Cllr Dimond does not deny that the motion's aim is one state in place of Israel: the objection is only to calling that racist. A single state with no Jewish homeland is what the motion's authors campaign for. Nine in ten British Jews regard Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people (Institute for Jewish Policy Research, 2010). In this campaign's view, that is why the motion is read by most British Jews as aimed at them.

  5. At 9:01: "And polls across Israel show that most Israelis, unfortunately, support genocide and..."

    No poll is named. About one in five of Israel's citizens is Arab, many of them Palestinian by identity. In this campaign's view, a claim made without a source by an elected councillor, that "most Israelis" support genocide, is a statement about a whole people.

  6. At 10:04: "And I don't think many people are going to fall for it, apart from the people that are..."

    Those who have called the motion wrong include the Prime Minister, the leader of the Liberal Democrats, the Board of Deputies of British Jews and four of the Green Party's own five MPs, who have rejected it in public.

  7. At 10:49: "So, I mean, there are some disagreements about certain parts of the motion. ... So..."

    The title is "Zionism is Racism". Cllr Dimond says Green councillors disagree with parts of the motion, and with its title. The Sheffield Green group's joint statement of 27 October did not say whether it supports the motion (The Star).

  8. At 15:58: "And just to say that that is Zionism in action, and that is what we are talking about...."

    The motion does not say that the demolition of homes in the West Bank, or the war in Gaza, is racist. It says Zionism is racism. Criticising what a government does needs no such motion. In this campaign's view, defining Zionism by the war is how the motion turns a belief most British Jews hold, that the Jewish people have a right to a homeland in their ancestral land, into a charge against them.

Read the transcript

An automatic transcript of the video, corrected for the councillors' names and the host's. The speakers are as the transcript separated them. The times are approximate. The video is above, so you can check every word against it.

0:00 Cllr Dimond: They've been supporting genocide for the last 3 years, but for them to lecture anyone and pretend that suddenly they have some red lines is absolutely ridiculous.

0:10 Cllr Thompson: The more time that goes by, the more I think passing this policy was absolutely the right thing to do.

0:17 Crispin Flintoff: Our next discussion is about the "Zionism is racism" motion, and how the Green Party is being vetoed by the Labour Party and by the Lib Dems. Joining me to talk about that is Alexi Dimond, who's a councillor in Sheffield. How are you doing, Alexi?

0:39 Cllr Dimond: I'm very well, thank you, and it's really good to see you. Thank you so much for inviting us on the show.

0:44 Crispin Flintoff: And Charli Thompson, who's a councillor in Barnet. She's also on the call.

0:50 Cllr Thompson: Hi, can you hear me?

0:52 Crispin Flintoff: I can. Thank you for coming on, Charlie. Good to see you. We've got Alexi in Sheffield, and you're in Barnet, who are both Green councillors. I just wanted to set the context of what's going on in this. The first thing was, we saw this clip last week of Andy Burnham.

1:11 Andy Burnham (clip): Can I condemn the motion that was passed? Unequivocally. It is wrong, it is anti-Semitic, and this side of the House will have nothing to do with it. And we will always take the right response when it comes to any partnerships we have with other parties. We cannot support a partnership with a party that holds a position that has recently been adopted.

1:35 Crispin Flintoff: And after Andy Burnham had made that move, we had this from Ed Davey, the Lib Dem leader: "I'm ruling out our party entering into a national partnership with any party that's committed to a dangerous and anti-Semitic policy like the Green Party's. Here is my letter to the Jewish Leadership Council and the Board of Deputies of British Jews." You can read that if you've got really good magnifying glass. I'm not going to read it myself, but if you want to, you can find it on a tweet. Alexi, what's your take on those two leaders attacking the Greens and saying they won't work with the Greens?

2:21 Cllr Dimond: Well, firstly, I have to say that it's disgusting conflation of Zionism and Judaism, which is what they constantly do. The leaders of the Labour Party and Labour politicians up and down the country, including in Sheffield. But also, for Ed Davey, particularly disappointing given the support for the genocide that the Board of Deputies has been continuing with throughout the last 3 years. And it's really gaslighting. I mean, these are politicians that have supported and are supporting genocide, and for them to criticize anyone for anything, especially when it comes to racism and the weaponization of anti-Semitism that they do, is really dangerous. And I think, you know, they should be ashamed of themselves. And it's just bullying as well. I mean, people with absolutely no morals bullying people for standing against genocide.

3:23 Cllr Dimond: That's exactly what it is. So, yeah, I think people up and down the country will see it for what it is. It's bullying, it's overreach, it's a different political party that has no commitment to democracy bullying a Democratic Party with, "We passed this motion with the biggest mandate," in, I think, one of the biggest Green Party conferences in history, with a lot of people attending that motion. And that has been the way that we've made policy. And to then suddenly throw it under the bus or criticize it just because you get a motion that some people don't like, I don't think it's a viable position. And, yeah, we won't be letting the Labour Party tell us what to do. I can speak a bit more about the local situation as well a bit later, but I might want to read...

4:16 Crispin Flintoff: That'd be great if you could say after, yeah. But Charlie, what was your response when you saw those two? I was quite shocked that they both used anti-Semitism so frequently when it's clearly about Zionism and there's a total difference between the two. I just found that extraordinary. What was your response to it?

4:40 Cllr Thompson: Thanks, Crispin. Well, I agree with Alexi. This is a distraction. This is disingenuous, bad faith. I think that when they talk about, you know, not wanting to work with the Greens and, you know, that they accuse us of, you know, idealism and, you know, "This wasn't a strategic move by the Green Party," you know? And yet here they are, being ideologues and saying, "We're not going to work with the Greens because of this thing." They will do everything in their power to defend Israel. And it just shows them for who they are, in my view. You know, I'm sure we'll talk more about this, but we had a motion in Barnet Council at full council this week. And a Jewish anti-Zionist resident of Barnet brought this question to the full council.

5:46 Cllr Thompson: And for people who are supposed to care about treating Jewish people well, they proceeded to holler and shout and, you know, be really, really aggressive and rude to this Jewish resident. And I just thought, you know, you don't care about Jewish safety. You're just... this is politics to you. And I think this is what this is about. It's political gesturing. It doesn't mean anything. We know we care. We're the people who care. We're on the right side of history. We're calling out genocide. And what are they doing? Just kind of, you know, trying to make themselves feel better because they don't want to look in the mirror. They don't want to face what they're doing and what they've been doing since, you know, since forever, really.

6:40 Crispin Flintoff: Yeah. And Alexi, you're sort of going to go into how it's impacted locally. But what is the situation if you don't work with Labour and they're saying, "We don't want to work with you," and stuff like that? How does that affect the Greens in Sheffield?

6:55 Cllr Dimond: Yes. So, well, in Sheffield, we are in an administration with Labour. We've actually just gone into that in May, after the most recent local elections, where Sheffield Green Party actually won the popular vote in Sheffield. But as a result of those elections, we were still the third biggest party, and the Lib Dems pulled out. So we've been, prior to that, in administration with Labour and the Lib Dems, and now it's just between us and Labour. But Labour have really shot themselves in the foot with this ultimatum and bullying tactic of saying, you know, "Renounce your own party's internal democracy or else." And they put out this statement. They're trying to weaponize anti-Semitism against us and conflating Zionism and Judaism, which is completely unacceptable. And basically, we've responded to that by saying, "Look, this is our party.

7:58 Cllr Dimond: It's our democracy. You can't push us around like this." And really, the ball's in their court. But I just wanted to go into some of the details about what they've... the sort of lies that they've been saying. So as well as weaponizing anti-Semitism against us, they also weaponized October the 7th. And the leader of Sheffield's... Sheffield Labour Party... said at a meeting that's sort of condemning our motion, again, conflating Zionism with Judaism and saying that we were racist for supporting... basically racist for supporting a one-state solution. And even wildly claiming that the majority of Israelis and Palestinians support a two-state solution. Now, what the hell is she basing that on, given that every party in the Israeli election has ruled out any sort of Palestinian state?

9:01 Cllr Dimond: And polls across Israel show that most Israelis, unfortunately, support genocide and expelling every Palestinian. So, you know, that is a lie. And how anyone could say that Palestinians... like, could accurately poll Palestinians when they've been living under the most brutal occupation for decades and, you know, suffering under Zionism for over a century now? It's just unbelievable. I mean, what I will say is that I don't think this overreach is going to go well down with Labour's electorate. And I think many people have reached out to us as the Green Group and sort of said how much they appreciate us speaking out, holding firm, being strong, not backing down to bullying. And everyone can see the gaslighting for what it is. You know, these are people that don't have any red lines whatsoever. You know, the Labour government has boasted about deporting record numbers of refugees.

10:04 Cllr Dimond: They support drilling and climate catastrophe. They've been supporting genocide for the last 3 years. But for them to lecture anyone and pretend that suddenly they have some red lines is absolutely ridiculous. And I don't think many people are going to fall for it, apart from the people that are completely, you know, brainwashed by the mainstream media and maybe watch BBC Radio 4 too much.

10:30 Crispin Flintoff: Can I just ask, sort of follow on on that? Obviously, they're trying to divide the Greens and make some councillors say, "Well, actually, maybe we shouldn't be following this policy." But has that had an impact on you in Sheffield? I mean, are there... is there a division going on now?

10:49 Cllr Dimond: So, I mean, there are some disagreements about certain parts of the motion. But I think what has really galvanized us is this ultimatum by Labour. So even if people were previously thinking, "Well, maybe the motion didn't need to have this phrase in it," or, "The title should have been different," or something like that, most people don't actually disagree with the substance of the motion. They might disagree on things like the tactics or efficacy of it. But what Labour have done in this ultimatum is galvanize people behind the position. Because, you know, it's just bullying. It's overreach. It's complete gaslighting. And it's, well, yeah.

11:34 Crispin Flintoff: So there may have been sort of disagreements on some of the ways of the motion, some parts of it. But because he's been using an anti-Semitic smearing campaign, a smear campaign, it's actually made people think, "Well, actually, this is unacceptable, and the motion's not the problem. It's the Labour Party and the Liberal Party." You know, so you don't even mention the Lib Dems, really, do you? But, Charlie, I'll unmute you as well. What's your experience been on other Green comrades' response to what Burnham and Ed Davey have said?

12:17 Cllr Thompson: Yeah. I mean, I'm in Barnet, and we have... I'm the only Green councillor, and I technically hold the balance of power in Barnet. But Labour and the Conservatives have decided to form a uni-party in order to not work with me, which is interesting. But, yeah, I've found a lot of Green comrades, it really... it's kind of just made us all the more determined, I think. The more time that goes by, the more I think passing this policy was absolutely the right thing to do. And, you know, as Alexi says, you know, "Who are these people to be lecturing us?" One of the comments that the leader of Barnet Council made at our meeting, or at the full council meeting, was, "Well, you know, only 0.1% of the membership of the Green Party voted for this motion, and, you know, you didn't consult with your membership." And I didn't have a chance to respond, but I'll respond now.

13:28 Cllr Thompson: Who are you in the Labour Party to be talking about party democracy when you have a top-down system? You decide the policy. The leadership decides the policy. In our party, we decide the policy. And actually, as Alexi said, you know, this was one of the biggest mandates we've had of any policy in the Green Party history. And there was a poll taken not long afterwards that showed that the majority of Green voters were fully behind it. So, and we've gone up two points in the polls. So all of this rhetoric is just... they're just so scared. They're so scared that we are doing the right thing and that the public are going to see that we stand on our morals and we are willing to say, "No, we're not going to... we're not going to have this, and we're going to call out genocide, and we're going to call out Zionism for the reason for that genocide." So, yeah, I don't think... I don't think they can really say anything else.

14:41 Cllr Thompson: And I think, you know, that has galvanized people in the Greens. I'm not going to lie, there are people in the Greens who don't agree with it. And there is a sense that, you know, there is the potential for this to create a bit of a divide. But quite honestly, I think the people making that harder, some of the people higher up in the Green Party who haven't kind of stuck with the membership, the grassroots membership, and I think that's done more damage than the actual passing of the policy.

15:14 Crispin Flintoff: Yeah. Alexi, what I was just thinking is, when is the next local election and when can this be tested? Because imagine an election where you've got all the other parties effectively saying, "We support the genocide," and one party saying, "We certainly don't support the genocide." I mean, that's not... they're going to struggle in there, aren't they? In that election, those parties. So what's your... when's the next election? And also, would you like to speak about some of the leaders in the Greens or some of the figures in the Greens trying to undermine the motion? What would you respond to on that?

15:58 Cllr Dimond: So, in terms of when we have the next elections in Sheffield, so they're not going to be in May. We elect every four years, and then we also have all-out elections in 2028. So, yes, it's going to be interesting times. But, yeah, in terms of... I just wanted to also say, like, well done to Charlie, because I watched footage of that meeting in Barnet, and they were absolutely awful. The way that they ganged up on her and the way that they sort of subverted processes to pass what is a really, really awful resolution. Really awful, like. But hopefully, people will have seen that and seen through it. And I just wanted to also bring it back to Gaza and the West Bank and what we're seeing today on our screens and the demolition of homes and the ongoing genocide, obviously, in Gaza, but now in the West Bank as well. And just to say that that is Zionism in action, and that is what we are talking about. And the motion that we passed was all about what Zionism is in action and how it is experienced by Palestinians.

17:05 Cllr Dimond: And nobody can say that that is not racist, and that is not racism. And to try and do that, just outrageous. And I did think at the conference, I just felt like no one who was arguing against the motion could actually argue against it on its merits or on the actual what's in there. And some of the arguments that were used against it were really disingenuous. And, you know, I include some of the leadership in that, especially coming up, like, after somebody like Stephen or, you know, somebody with experience, a Jewish Holocaust survivor, and then just rubbishing what he said. And then after Lubna had made a really impassioned speech about what Zionism has meant as a Palestinian, all the members of her family that have been dispossessed and killed and many times over. And just to say, "No, we know better than that," is absolutely appalling, to be honest. But, yeah, I mean, so I think, yeah, maybe it's an electoral thing.

18:12 Cllr Dimond: You know, if you've got a Tory-facing seat, you've won a seat from a Tory, then you might be doing it. But that's not what Greens are about. You know, our slogan was "Speaking truth to power." And if you speak to truth to power on some things and not others, that's not really doing justice to that sort of... you know, we have to stand by our principles, right? And I don't... this is a litmus test, really, isn't it? Gaza and Palestine. If you can't stand with Palestine as it's being genocided, as a genocide is going on, you know, really, you don't have any morals at all. And that's what I would say on that.

18:49 Crispin Flintoff: Charlie, but I'm not a Green, but I'm not in the Greens, but I do worry that if these leadership people try and stop it and mess around and expel people or whatever these sort of rumors are that the media are trying to put out there, it would be really demoralizing for everyone who supports Palestine. But if the grassroots can see off that, then it will be really exciting. And everyone, you know, the Greens will really go places. Is that how you see it? And this is like a make or break. If you keep this going, then it will... the polls will totally change. I mean, you're going up a bit. It will really go up, won't it?

19:35 Cllr Thompson: Yeah. I mean, I think that. And I think what people need to remember is that, you know, the leaders are... we have a one-member, one-vote system, and the leaders are one member, individual members. So they can say all of this stuff in the media, and they can try and put pressure on Zack. Zack has come out already and said he's not going to, you know, undo this motion. He can't. If anybody wants to change this motion, they're going to have to go through the party processes. You know, there's talks about potentially changing the way in which we make policy, but they're going to have to persuade members who've, you know, this is one of the fundamental kind of... it's a foundation of the Green Party that we are democratic. It's going to be really hard to change the grassroots mind about that. You know, also, there are people who have left the Labour Party and joined the Greens.

20:38 Cllr Thompson: I'm one of those people. I don't want to be in a party that's like Labour that, you know, can dictate from the top down. So I think, you know, ultimately, the members will decide. And I have confidence that, you know, our growth in membership hasn't come from us not being democratic or from, you know, weak policy on stuff. Our growth in membership has come from our bold politics, the fact we've stood on our morals, and the fact that we are democratic. So, yeah, I'm not so sure that they'll be able to do what they think they want to do. And I would urge them to reconsider, you know, going out in the media and kind of undermining the values of the Green Party in this way, which is what I think they're doing.

In the news

8 news stories naming Cllr Alexi Dimond

  1. "I stand full square with the Jewish community": Sheffield councillor Matt Smith puts his name to it, and is "ashamed" of the Sheffield councillors who backed the motionCllr Matt Smith, writing to this campaign
  2. Sheffield's Green leaders say Labour was "political point scoring" over "a Green Party national policy position". Here is what that policy saysThe Star (Local Democracy Reporting Service)
  3. Sheffield's Labour leader on why the administration ended: Cllr Ahmed's posts were "blatantly antisemitic", and "in any other party, he would have been suspended instantly"The Star (Rose Mason, Local Democracy Reporting Service)
  4. "A self-absorbed, self-indulgent psychodrama": Sheffield's Liberal Democrats move to strip Cllrs Dimond and Raouf of their committee chairs, and lose by 34 to 39. Cllr Clement-Jones: "a nasty policy by a nasty party"The Star
  5. Cllr Belbin: Sheffield Greens have confirmed "Zionism is not inherently racist", so Labour will carry on. The Greens' statement says Labour's councillor is "plainly lying", the motion stands, and nothing about ZionismCllr Fran Belbin, on Facebook
  6. Sheffield Green Party calls Cllr Rusling "plainly lying" over "the elimination of Israel by violent means". The motion's own words: "a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine", by "all available means"Sheffield Green Party, on Facebook
  7. Two Green councillors who backed the motion, Sheffield's Alexi Dimond and Barnet's Charli Thompson, on video: "we're going to call out Zionism for the reason for that genocide"The Crispin Flintoff Show, on YouTube
  8. Sheffield's Green planning chair will not resign: "I will not let the yellow or red army bully me", and "Zionism is racism, that is Green Party policy as of now"The Star, Sheffield

What they put in writing

“We do recognise there is a diversity of beliefs among people who identify as Zionists, and accept that some people who identify as Zionists disagree with the ideology of political Zionism as practiced by the Israeli state and are not racist.”

Cllr Alexi Dimond, Green Party councillor for Gleadless Valley ward, Sheffield, backed the motion in public, as Facebook comment, as The Star reported reported on 3 November 2026. A comment on an It's Our City! post on Facebook on the evening of 3 November, replying to Cllr Belbin, as The Star reported on 4 November. These are the words Cllr Belbin described to full council the next day as the Greens confirming that Zionism is not inherently racist. The comment says some Zionists are not racist: those who "disagree with the ideology of political Zionism as practiced by the Israeli state". It does not reject the motion. Their words are quoted exactly from that report.

Cllr Dimond: if this report has misunderstood you, tell us and we will correct the record straight away.

Is Zionism racism? No.

Why Cllr Dimond is wrong

What Cllr Dimond said, and why it is wrong

Read it closely. The Zionists Cllr Dimond accepts are not racist are those who "disagree with the ideology of political Zionism": that is, a Zionist is not a racist so long as the Zionist is against Zionism. Everyone else who holds the belief, which is most British Jews, stays where the motion put them. This is the sentence Sheffield Labour took, for a week, as the Greens confirming that Zionism is not inherently racist. It says no such thing.

Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find, including many who are fierce critics of Israeli governments.

Cllr Dimond signed the open letter of Green councillors who "support the 'Zionism is Racism' motion", and has said of what the motion describes: "nobody can say that that is not racist". Nothing in this comment withdraws either. The motion does not condemn "political Zionism as practiced by the Israeli state". It declares Zionism itself racism, to be "treated as any other form of racism", and that is the policy Cllr Dimond still supports.

The working definition of antisemitism of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, adopted by the UK Government, gives as an example "denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor".

In 1975 the United Nations General Assembly declared that "Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination". In 1991 it revoked that, by 111 votes to 25. The Green Party has brought back the line the world withdrew, and one of its own councillors has backed it in public.

What the motion's authors really sayThe motion, line by line

Councillors of every other party are saying the opposite

Councillors and MPs of every party in England and Wales are putting their names to one sentence: Zionism is not racism. See who has signed, or ask your own councillors and MP to sign.