
Would not reject it
Green Party councillor
Cllr Angela Argenzio
Broomhill and Sharrow Vale ward, Sheffield
Asked to reject the motion, they would not. Reported saying: “You know that the Green Councillors are not antisemitic. Conflating Zionism with Judaism is itself antisemitic. ... If Labour chooses to destabilise Sheffield City Council over this, Labour owns the consequences.”
- Party
- Green Party
- Reported
- 16 October 2026
Tell them why it’s wrongWhy Zionism is not racismThe councillors who backed the motion
In the news
7 news stories naming Cllr Angela Argenzio
- "I stand full square with the Jewish community": Sheffield councillor Matt Smith puts his name to it, and is "ashamed" of the Sheffield councillors who backed the motionCllr Matt Smith, writing to this campaign
- Sheffield's Green leaders say Labour was "political point scoring" over "a Green Party national policy position". Here is what that policy saysThe Star (Local Democracy Reporting Service)
- The Green Party on Sheffield: the Greens "stood firmly by their principles", Labour's demands were "rejected", and Andy Burnham's "authoritarian diktat" has failed. The word Zionism does not appearThe Green Party, press release
- Sheffield: Labour ends its power-sharing with the Greens. "Our trust in Sheffield Greens is completely broken"Jewish News
- At least three Green groups do not reject the motion after Labour's ultimatum: Derbyshire Dales, Havant and SheffieldLocal Government Chronicle
- Ten days on, Sheffield's Green group has still not rejected the motion, and the city's Labour and Green administration hangs on itThe Star, Sheffield
- Sheffield's Green group refuses Labour's ultimatum: "If Labour chooses to destabilise Sheffield City Council over this, Labour owns the consequences"The Star, Sheffield
Their refusal, in writing
“You know that the Green Councillors are not antisemitic. Conflating Zionism with Judaism is itself antisemitic. ... If Labour chooses to destabilise Sheffield City Council over this, Labour owns the consequences.”
Cllr Angela Argenzio, Green Party councillor for Broomhill and Sharrow Vale ward, Sheffield, was asked to reject the motion and would not, as The Star (Sheffield) reported on 16 October 2026. Her open letter of 16 October 2026, as leader of the Green group on Sheffield City Council, answering the Labour council leader's ultimatum that the Greens publicly reject the motion, as The Star quoted it; "..." marks words left out. She did not reject the motion. Jewish News reported on 27 October 2026 that she refused Labour's ultimatum. Their words are quoted exactly from that report.
Cllr Argenzio: if this report has misunderstood you, tell us and we will correct the record straight away.
Is Zionism racism? No.
Why Zionism is not racism
What Cllr Argenzio said, and why it is wrong
Nobody has to conflate Zionism with Judaism to see what the motion does. Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find, including many who are fierce critics of Israeli governments. A policy that treats that belief as racism, "as any other form of racism", lands on most Jews whether or not it names them. That is not a conflation; it is arithmetic.
The definition of antisemitism adopted by the UK Government, the IHRA working definition, gives as one of its examples "claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor". The motion rejects that definition. It also rejects the Jerusalem Declaration, the alternative its critics prefer. Saying "we are not antisemitic" while discarding both yardsticks is not an answer; it is a refusal to be measured.
As for consequences: the Labour Party's condition was one sentence, that Sheffield's Green councillors reject the motion. The Leader of Sheffield's Green group was asked, as every Green councillor on this site has been, to say that Zionism is not racism. She has not. The consequences of that choice are hers, and the Jewish residents of Sheffield are entitled to read it as she wrote it.
The working definition of antisemitism of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, adopted by the UK Government, gives as an example "denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor".
In 1975 the United Nations General Assembly declared that "Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination". In 1991 it revoked that, by 111 votes to 25. The Green Party has brought back the line the world withdrew, and an elected councillor of another party, asked to say in one sentence that Zionism is not racism, has refused in writing.
What the motion's authors really sayThe motion, line by line
Councillors of every other party are saying the opposite
Councillors and MPs of every party in England and Wales are putting their names to one sentence: Zionism is not racism. See who has signed, or ask your own councillors and MP to sign.