
Said it in public
Green Party councillor
Cllr Eden Hills
Little London and Woodhouse ward, Leeds
Reported saying: “Leeds City Council is about to debate a motion that says Zionism is not racism, at a time when Israel is committing a genocide against the Palestinian people. This is outrageous. Zionism is the state ideology of Israel, an apartheid state, according to the ICJ, that gives Palestinians fewer rights on the basis of their ethnicity. Is that not racist? Help us oppose this motion.”
- Party
- Green Party
- Reported
- 10 November 2026
Tell them why it’s wrongWhy Cllr Hills is wrongThe councillors who backed the motion
Outside Leeds Civic Hall, posted 10 November 2026
"Help us oppose this motion": Cllr Eden Hills calls a demonstration against Leeds City Council saying Zionism is not racism
On 10 November 2026 Cllr Eden Hills, Green councillor for Little London and Woodhouse on Leeds City Council, posted this video on Instagram, filmed outside Leeds Civic Hall, the day before the council's full meeting was due to debate a motion that says Zionism is not racism. It ends on a card reading "ZIONISM IS RACISM. 11:15 WED 11TH NOV. LEEDS CIVIC HALL." Here it is in full, with a transcript, and what is wrong with it.
What is wrong with it
"A motion that frames anti-Zionism as being opposed to Jewish people"
The video shows part of the motion on screen, over the name of Cllr Mark Dobson of the Garforth and Swillington Independents. The part shown condemns the Green Party conference's resolution declaring Zionism to be racism, and states the council's "unwavering commitment to challenging antisemitism in all its forms". Saying that Zionism is not racism does not say that every Jewish person is a Zionist. It says that the belief is not racism.
"That motion conflates Zionism with Judaism ... not all Jewish people are Zionists"
Nobody claims they all are. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find, and the Board of Deputies of British Jews, their elected representative body, resolved by 118 votes to 1 on 25 October that the Green Party had become a racist party over its motion. In this campaign's view, that a minority of Jews say the Green motion is acceptable does not make it so for the majority it describes as racists.
"Zionism is the state ideology of Israel"
Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like every other people, have the right to self-determination in a homeland of their own. It is held by most Jews in Britain, most of whom have never voted in an Israeli election. A person can hold it and oppose everything an Israeli government does, as many Israelis do. The Green motion does not say an Israeli government is racist. It says the belief is.
"An apartheid state, according to the ICJ"
The International Court of Justice's advisory opinion of 19 July 2024 was about Israel's policies and practices in the occupied Palestinian territory. It found that Israel's legislation and measures there breach Article 3 of the convention against racial discrimination, the article on "racial segregation and apartheid", without saying which of the two. It did not rule that Israel is "an apartheid state". About a fifth of Israel's citizens are Arab; they vote, sit in its parliament and on its Supreme Court.
"Israel is committing a genocide"
The video states this as settled fact. No court has ruled it. In the case South Africa brought at the International Court of Justice in December 2023, the Court has ordered provisional measures; the claim itself has not been decided. And whatever a court decides about a government's conduct in a war, it is not a finding about the belief that the Jewish people have a homeland, which is what Leeds's motion is about.
"We say never again, not just for one group of people"
The video cuts to a clip of the speaker Cllr Hills calls "our party leader", saying: "because I'm Jewish, I grew up with the story of the Holocaust. And we say never again, not just for one group of people, but for all groups of people." In this campaign's view, for most Jewish families "never again" is the reason they hold that the Jewish people need a homeland of their own. The clip is used here to rally a demonstration against a council saying that belief is not racism.
What the demonstration is against
The video's caption says the demonstration is for "ending British complicity in genocide". Its closing card says "ZIONISM IS RACISM", and its last words are "Help us oppose this motion." The motion it opposes is a council saying that Zionism is not racism and that it will challenge antisemitism. It is called for 11:15am on 11 November, Armistice Day, outside the council's meeting.
Read the transcript
A transcript made from the recording and checked against the video's own captions. The times are approximate. The video is above, so you can check every word against it.
0:00 Cllr Hills: Leeds City Council is about to debate a motion that says Zionism is not racism, at a time when Israel is committing a genocide against the Palestinian people. This is outrageous. Zionism is the state ideology of Israel, an apartheid state, according to the ICJ, that gives Palestinians fewer rights on the basis of their ethnicity. Is that not racist?
0:17 Cllr Hills: This Wednesday, at Leeds' November full council meeting, the Garforth independents, working with the Conservatives, are putting together a motion that frames anti-Zionism as being opposed to Jewish people. That motion conflates Zionism with Judaism. In reality, not all Zionists are Jewish, and not all Jewish people are Zionists.
0:34 Cllr Hills: There's always been a strong anti-Zionist Jewish movement opposed to the Israeli project. In the UK, Jewish voices are at the heart of the anti-Zionist movement, including our party leader.
0:43 Clip of the party leader: And because I'm Jewish, I grew up with the story of the Holocaust. And we say never again, not just for one group of people, but for all groups of people.
0:53 Cllr Hills: So this Wednesday, there'll be a demonstration here outside Civic Hall. People from Leeds are coming together to oppose British complicity in the ongoing genocide against Palestinians. Details below. Help us oppose this motion.
1:05 Closing card: ZIONISM IS RACISM. 11:15 WED 11TH NOV. LEEDS CIVIC HALL.
In the news
3 news stories naming Cllr Eden Hills
- Leeds City Council votes 81 to 11 to reject the notion that Zionism is racismLeeds City Council, full council meeting
- Cllr Eden Hills, a Leeds Green councillor who backed the motion, calls a "Zionism is Racism" demonstration against the council saying Zionism is not racism, at 11:15am on Armistice Day. What the video says, and what is wrong with itCllr Eden Hills, on Instagram
- A Leeds Green councillor, Cllr Cristiana Mirosanu, calls a "Support Zionism is Racism motion" protest outside Leeds Civic Hall on Armistice Day, with the Socialist Workers Party, Workers Power and Leeds Palestine Solidarity CampaignInstagram
What they put in writing
“Leeds City Council is about to debate a motion that says Zionism is not racism, at a time when Israel is committing a genocide against the Palestinian people. This is outrageous. Zionism is the state ideology of Israel, an apartheid state, according to the ICJ, that gives Palestinians fewer rights on the basis of their ethnicity. Is that not racist? Help us oppose this motion.”
Cllr Eden Hills, Green Party councillor for Little London and Woodhouse ward, Leeds, backed the motion in public, as Instagram reported on 10 November 2026. In a video posted on Instagram on 10 November 2026, calling a demonstration outside Leeds Civic Hall against the council's motion that Zionism is not racism. The video ends on a card reading "ZIONISM IS RACISM". Their words are quoted exactly from that report.
Cllr Hills: if this report has misunderstood you, tell us and we will correct the record straight away.
Is Zionism racism? No.
Why Cllr Hills is wrong
What Cllr Hills said, and why it is wrong
Three claims, none of them what it seems. "According to the ICJ": the International Court of Justice's advisory opinion of 19 July 2024 was about Israel's policies in the occupied Palestinian territory. It did not rule that Israel is "an apartheid state". "Committing a genocide": no court has ruled it; the case South Africa brought in December 2023 has not been decided. "The state ideology of Israel": Zionism is a belief held by most Jews in Britain, most of whom have never voted in an Israeli election.
Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find, including many who are fierce critics of Israeli governments.
"Is that not racist?" Cllr Hills asks. The question confuses a government with a people. About a fifth of Israel's citizens are Arab; they vote, sit in its parliament and have sat on its Supreme Court. Whatever is said of the occupation, it is a charge against policy, and Zionists make it too. The motion Leeds debated said only that the belief is not racism, and the next day the council agreed, by 81 votes to 11.
The working definition of antisemitism of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, adopted by the UK Government, gives as an example "denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor".
In 1975 the United Nations General Assembly declared that "Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination". In 1991 it revoked that, by 111 votes to 25. The Green Party has brought back the line the world withdrew, and one of its own councillors has backed it in public.
What the motion's authors really sayThe motion, line by line
Councillors of every other party are saying the opposite
Councillors and MPs of every party in England and Wales are putting their names to one sentence: Zionism is not racism. See who has signed, or ask your own councillors and MP to sign.