These councillors say Zionism is racism
Tell them
Racist

The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist. Why

"Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026, hosted by Tony Greenstein

Their webinar of 1 July 2026, line by line

On 7 May 2026 the Green Party Council voted to expel Tony Greenstein. On 1 July he hosted an 89-minute webinar which, he said, Greens for Palestine "was sponsoring ... in fact, still is sponsoring". Six of the nine speakers withdrew after the party warned that speaking could mean suspension. A Green Party officer in Bournemouth and a suspended Liberal Democrat councillor spoke anyway. We have listened to every minute. Here is what was said, quoted exactly with the time, and why it is wrong.

89
minutes, every one listened to
13
quotations, each with its time
6
speakers who withdrew under threat of suspension
1
party that still put its name to it

Criticising Israeli governments, the occupation or the conduct of the war in Gaza is not antisemitism, and nothing on this page says it is. Jews who oppose Zionism are as Jewish as any other Jews, and Tony Greenstein is Jewish. What follows is about what was said of Jews, of Israel and the Nazis, of antisemitism itself, and about who said it under whose name.

  1. The party had just expelled the host for, in its own words, "repeated instances of anti-Semitism". Greens for Palestine sponsored his webinar anyway, and kept its name on it after the party's warning emptied the platform.

  2. The host told the audience there is no criticism of Israel that can be antisemitic, that Israel "bears a very great similarity to Nazi Germany", that antisemitism is "so much glitter ... not real", that British Jews are "the favourite colonial pets of the British government", and that he supported "the uprising on October the 7th".

  3. A Green candidate the party suspended the night before polling day called its leader "much weaker than all other leaders", the party "totally corrupted", and ended "From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free". Every speaker tied the defence of the suspended to passing the "Zionism is racism" motion in the autumn.

Who put their name to it

2 quotations

What they say

There's been a complete panic around this meeting, that threats were made, that people could be suspended or even expelled if they were to speak here on the platform. So we have a reduced number of speakers. ... Greens for Palestine, which was sponsoring this meeting, in fact, still is sponsoring this meeting, took fright.

Tony Greenstein, who hosted, at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 0:00:00 to 0:01:17, and 0:22:46)

What is wrong with it

The Green Party Council voted to expel Tony Greenstein on 7 May 2026, citing, in the notice he read out at 1:00:38, "repeated instances of anti-Semitism". Greens for Palestine sponsored his webinar seven weeks later and, by his account, kept sponsoring it after the party's warning had cut the speakers from nine to three. The co-chair put it at 1:14:35: "six people haven't felt able to speak who were supposed to be speaking".

A Green Party officer spoke regardless: "I'm in the BCP Green Party as events coordinator" (0:41:24). So did a suspended Green member (1:23:56) and a suspended Liberal Democrat councillor (1:09:09). The party knew; its warning is why the others stayed away.

What they say

Can you see a way, a very strong way, in which holding the webinar this evening and supporting the Zionist as racism motion at Conference in October are both part of the same fight? ... the Zionism is racism motion, which I hope will be passed at the Autumn Conference ... everybody should do their level best to support Lubna Speitan and her team passing this motion because Zionism is racism ... help get the Zionism as racism passed in the Autumn Conference.

Claire Brown, from the audience, and the answers of the host, of Feda Shahin, a Green Party candidate in Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole in May 2026, suspended the night before the poll, and of the BCP Green Party events coordinator, at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 0:48:41, 0:26:04, 0:54:03 and 0:44:36)

What is wrong with it

The webinar's own answer to its own question: defending members suspended over antisemitism and passing the "Zionism is racism" motion were "the same fight". Three months later the party passed the motion, and the councillors on this site are the ones who put their names to it.

What the host said of Jews, Israel and antisemitism

7 quotations

What they say

There is no criticism you can make of Israel that is anti-Semitic, for the very simple reason that Israel is not a human being. It's not a person. It's a state.

Tony Greenstein, who hosted, at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 0:24:00)

What is wrong with it

The definition adopted by the UK Government, most councils and the Green Party's own leadership says criticism of Israel "similar to that leveled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic", and then lists what can: holding Jews collectively responsible for Israel's actions, denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, and comparing Israeli policy to that of the Nazis. The host did the last of those within ten minutes.

What they say

I said that Israel was Hitler's bastard offspring. ... who can deny that Israel bears a very great similarity to Nazi Germany? ... Yoav Gallant, the Defense Minister, who called Palestinians human animals. And this was the exact phrase that Heinrich Himmler, the head of the SS, also used about Jews.

Tony Greenstein, who hosted, at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 0:33:58 to 0:35:22)

What is wrong with it

Israel as Nazi Germany, its defence minister as Himmler. "Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis" is one of the examples of antisemitism in the definition the UK Government uses. He said he was arrested for a racially aggravated offence for saying it before (0:52:09), and said it again, at an event a Green Party group sponsored.

What they say

I'm being prosecuted under the Terrorism Act for support for a prescribed organisation, Hamas, because I supported the uprising on October the 7th.

Tony Greenstein, who hosted, at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 0:59:24)

What is wrong with it

On 7 October 2023 Hamas and others murdered some 1,200 people in Israel, most of them civilians, and took 251 hostages. That is "the uprising" the host says he supported. Hamas has been proscribed in full in the UK since November 2021. This is the man whose webinar Greens for Palestine chose to sponsor.

What they say

Jews in this country are used as the moral alibi for what imperialism does. ... the police have been told that Jews are their favourite clients, the favourite colonial pets of the British government.

Tony Greenstein, who hosted, at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 0:51:08 to 0:53:09)

What is wrong with it

British Jews as "colonial pets" and the state's "alibi": a people reduced to a tool of the government, which is the oldest shape the hatred takes. The Community Security Trust recorded 3,528 antisemitic incidents in 2024, the second worst year on record, after 4,103 in 2023. Those are the "favourite clients" he describes.

What they say

All of this stuff about anti-Semitism is really just so much glitter. ... It's not real. ... it's a complete distraction when they accuse people of anti-Semitism, because we know that's not what it's about.

Tony Greenstein, who hosted, at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 0:49:55 and 0:52:09)

What is wrong with it

Said to Green Party members, some of them suspended over their own words, as the reason they need feel no shame. A member of the audience who introduced herself as a Holocaust child survivor agreed: "anti-Semitism accusations and campaigns ... total rubbish" (1:05:56). Nobody on the call disagreed.

What they say

It is understandable you can be pro-Zionist and anti-Semitic, because after all, if you don't want Jews in your country, then Zionism is a really good solution. You send them to Palestine. ... the whole basis of Zionism is really a reflection of anti-Semitism.

Tony Greenstein, who hosted, at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 0:32:51 to 0:33:58)

What is wrong with it

Zionism as the antisemites' "solution", and so itself a form of antisemitism: the belief of most British Jews, that Israel should exist, turned into a slur on them. This is the argument of the motion the party passed, made by the man the party expelled, at an event its supporters sponsored.

What they say

I seriously wonder whether she would have told people during the Third Reich that you've got to be less toxic about criticizing Nazi Germany, because you might offend German people in this country. ... the influence of Saint Caroline is very important ... it's really, it's a lack of moral courage.

Tony Greenstein, who hosted, and Mike, from the audience, in Suffolk, at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 0:28:43, and 0:39:15 to 0:40:35)

What is wrong with it

Caroline Lucas, the party's former leader, had asked for the debate to be "held in a less toxic way". For that she was likened to an apologist for the Third Reich, and her Jewish colleagues to "German people in this country". The audience member's complaint was that she "doesn't want to offend those people".

What the suspended candidates said

3 quotations

What they say

I do not believe that Zack Polanski is different from any other leader. I think even he's much weaker than all other leaders. ... I think the Green Party is totally corrupted. ... the Labour MP Jessica Toale, and I called her before and I call her again, Jessica Troll, because this is what she's doing. ... So I would like to end with, "From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free."

Feda Shahin, a Green Party candidate in Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole in May 2026, suspended the night before the poll, at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 0:12:42, 0:18:22, 0:14:49 and 1:21:11)

What is wrong with it

A Green Party candidate in May 2026 who, by her own account, was suspended by email "less than 11 hours" before the poll and told nobody so that the vote would not suffer. The Spectator and the Times of Israel had reported posts of hers in April saying "the Zionists killed 20 million Christians" in the Soviet Union; the party acted on the eve of polling day. She calls the party "totally corrupted", mocks the Member of Parliament for Bournemouth West by name, and ends with the chant that leaves no room for Israel between the river and the sea.

She also told the audience the party's suspensions were "an engineered stupidity to get rid of the people, including Muslim people, including activists, Palestinians" (0:18:22). The party had suspended her for what she had written, not for who she is.

What they say

I'm gate-crashing this meeting. My name is Sam. I'm a Lib Dem. ... I have been suspended. ... it's mostly Labour Jewish Movement who was quoted in an article of Jewish News. My post said that the NEC is controlled by political thugs who are influenced by the Israeli lobby. ... Jewish Labour Movement went after me, even though I'm a Lib Dem, and it worked.

Sam Ammar, a Liberal Democrat district councillor in Bromsgrove and county councillor in Worcestershire, suspended by her party, at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 1:09:09 to 1:12:38)

What is wrong with it

The Liberal Democrats suspended Cllr Ammar on 6 May 2026, Jewish News reported, over posts about "the Israel lobby" and "paymasters". Two months later she was on a platform with a man expelled for antisemitism, asking for a cross-party network to help "people who do get suspended". The Liberal Democrats' leader has since called the motion "dangerous and antisemitic"; she remains a Liberal Democrat councillor.

What they say

One of the things that Tony has said repeatedly is you should think of the Zionists as exactly like the Nazis. ... I think this business of comparing Zionists to Nazis, which is a very fair comparison ... why anybody, anybody with the remotest moral compass would say, I'm a Zionist, like in fact Andy Burnham does, interestingly, is extraordinary to me.

Malcolm, from the audience, who said he was "not part of any Green Party", at the webinar "Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism", 1 July 2026 (automated transcript of the recording, 0:45:22 to 0:47:40)

What is wrong with it

Most British Jews are Zionists in the only sense that matters: they think Israel should exist. Here that makes them "exactly like the Nazis", and the Prime Minister without "the remotest moral compass". Andy Burnham's view of the motion, given in the House of Commons: "It is wrong. It is antisemitic, and this side of the House will have nothing to do with it."

Taken together

What it adds up to

Nothing on this page was said by the Green Party. All of it was said at an event its supporters' group sponsored, by the man the party had expelled, by the candidate it had suspended, and by the members and officers who came anyway; and every one of them said the way to answer the party was to pass its "Zionism is racism" motion. The party passed it on 4 October 2026.

Zionism is not racism. Green councillors can say so by signing the pledge; councillors and MPs of every other party, by adding their name.

Green councillors: sign the pledge Other councillors and MPs: add your name

Quotations are from an automated transcript of the recording "Greens 4 Palestine Webinar 1 July 2026: 'Reinstate Our Members: Anti-Zionism is not Anti-Semitism'" (YouTube, uploaded 2 July 2026), with the time in the video. They are quoted for criticism and review.