
Said it in public
Green Party councillor
Cllr Mark Adderley
Crystal Palace and Upper Norwood ward, Croydon
Reported saying: “We are Green councillors who support the "Zionism is Racism" motion passed at the Green Party conference on 4th October 2026.”
- Party
- Green Party
- Reported
- 19 October 2026
Tell them why it’s wrongWhy Cllr Adderley is wrongThe councillors who backed the motion
Their own video, 24 October 2026
Cllr Adderley's video about this site
On 24 October 2026 Cllr Adderley posted a video on Instagram scrolling through this site, their own page on it and the evidence file, and talking about them. Here it is in full, with a transcript, and what is wrong with it.
What is wrong with it
Not one quotation is disputed
Cllr Adderley says the site is "all in the opinion of whoever set up this". The categories are the file's assessment, and the councillor's page in it says so. The items are not opinion: each is the councillor's own public post or reported words, dated, with its source, and a screenshot where one was taken. In this video Cllr Adderley says: "They do quote a lot of what I've said, and I read it and I found myself just sitting there nodding," and "I've said a lot more than that, and I'll say it again." Not one item is named as wrong.
Writing to a councillor is not McCarthyism
The objection is that the site encourages people "to contact us all via our councillor emails". Councils publish those addresses so that the public can write to their councillors. McCarthyism meant Senate and congressional hearings, blacklists and people losing their jobs for their politics. "Kafkaesque" means being accused without being told the charge. Here the "charge" is the councillor's own words, set out in full, and the page invites them to tell us if anything is wrong so that it can be corrected.
A joke made of it
Cllr Adderley calls the list "the best season yet" for a Spurs fan, and suggests repeating every statement so as to be "right at the top of the Premiership". In this campaign's view, treating a record of public statements about Israel and Zionists as a football league shows how lightly the councillor takes what the motion means to British Jews.
"Told by a Zionist": the motion's problem in one sentence
Cllr Adderley says that being told anything "by a Zionist" is "water off a duck's back", and calls the criticism "bad-faith Zionist smear campaigns". Nine in ten British Jews regard Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people (Institute for Jewish Policy Research, 2010). In this campaign's view, waving away anyone who is a Zionist waves away most British Jews before they have said a word, and that is exactly what makes the motion racist: it turns a belief most Jews hold into a reason not to listen to them.
"Something slightly illegal"
In the longer livestream Cllr Adderley says there is "a big chance that there is something slightly illegal" about this site, and that "a few people" are "looking into who they are". No law is named. In the same breath, Cllr Adderley says that defamation "is if they quote you and say you said something you didn't say", and that the site quotes accurately: "they do quote a lot of what I've said". Every item on the page is the councillor's own public words, with its source, and the page invites a correction of anything wrong; on air, the answer to that invitation was: "You haven't got all of my best bits."
Zionism "unfortunately racist", in their own words
Cllr Adderley tells the stream what to say to a constituent who is a Zionist: "I'm not sitting here calling you an avowed racist. But I believe that the ideology ... is unfortunately racist." In this campaign's view, that is the motion in one sentence: most British Jews hold that belief about their own people, and an elected councillor tells them it is racist.
The video's own caption gets it wrong
The caption reads "Zionist website targets 92 Green councillors". The site does not target anyone: it shows what councillors who back the motion have said in public, in their own words, and asks readers to write to them, politely, about why the motion is wrong. Every councillor on it is offered the chance to correct anything it has wrong.
Read the transcript
An automatic transcript of the recording, with the words read out from the screen in quotation marks. The video is above, so you can check every word against it. A viewer named in the video is not named here.
0:00 So there's a website... Here we go, look, this is the front page. "These councillors say Zionism is racism. Ninety-two councillors. Back the racist motion. Tell them why it's wrong." And this is a website that's been designed to list, outline, collate the statements that many of us have made. They've turned it almost into a sort of... like a league table. They have little kind of things like this, the evidence file. "Seventy-two of the councillors who back the Zionism is racism motion have said in public since 7 October." They have different categories in their opinion. And don't forget, this is all in the opinion of whoever set up this, uh, this account. "The councillors, gravest first." And so then they have a countdown, or a list, which someone else has managed to pull into a league table. It's curious, this. Because look, look, here's the league table. Have a look at that league table. Oh God, I thought... I thought I was up there at the top through my surname, being an A. And then you go to my page and there's this really quite menacing photo of me with a green background.
0:48 I look like something from the Addams Family. "Councillor Mark Adderley." Look at... the bit that makes me roar with laughter is look at the red ring around my incredibly, deathly, like, pallor face. Red circle. "Put it in writing." I put it in writing. They do quote a lot of what I've said, and I read it and I found myself just sitting there nodding. "Reported saying, 'We are Green councillors,'" God forbid, "'who support the Zionism is racism motion.'" There's such a sense of surety and such a lack of doubt in the application of this and creation of this website that quoting me saying something that is deeply uncontroversial is seen as somehow a slam dunk. "Put it in... he put it in writing." And I've said a lot more than that, and I'll say it again. These are my crimes. Twenty-four sit in the category of B, "Criticism of Israel or related activism". Six sit as a "Statement on the motion". Six are "Context and mitigating statements". It's not helping the fact that I look like Frankenstein. Now, this is the part of it that I think is troubling.
1:46 They're encouraging people to contact us all via our councillor emails. This is a form of McCarthy... McCarthy-esque style. Not even McCarthy-esque. This is... this is Kafka-esque. [A viewer's name], I think that's hysterical that you said that. I'm in a... I was talking to a number of co-councillors about this, and when I saw the league table, I said, "Jesus Christ, as a Spurs fan, this is the best season yet." What I thought of doing, which could really completely screw or confuse their algorithm up, is I thought I could reread every one of my bits of evidence, and then they'd have to re-upload them as more evidence. Suddenly I'd have 70. I'd be right at the top of the Premiership. I'm being very gallows humour about it, but you know, for some this is disturbing, it's worrying. To be characterised as a racist. I mean, I've now been characterised as a racist and an antisemite for so long, I suppose I've got a thicker skin. Because I know fundamentally and profoundly I'm not. I know how, uh, contorted the bad-faith Zionist smear campaigns are.
2:38 I know how unself-aware Zionism is. So to be told I'm anything, actually, by a Zionist is becoming, not always, but is becoming increasingly water off a duck's back.
The full livestream, on YouTube
The Instagram clip is cut from a longer YouTube livestream, "US & Israel to Strike IRAN; Islamophobic Paris Attack; Zionist Website TARGETS Green Councillors", in which Cllr Adderley talks about this site from 29:59. In the longer version, Cllr Adderley also says:
28:56 If someone was one of my constituents and said, "Look, I'm a Zionist, and I think it's wrong what you're saying," ... "I'm not sitting here calling you an avowed racist. But I believe that the ideology, if you're calling yourself a Zionist ... it is unfortunately racist."
31:50 Don't forget, this is all in the opinion of whoever set up this account. I'm still... we've got a few people looking into who they are, actually, because there is a big chance that there is something slightly illegal about what they're doing with this website.
33:20 Well, defamation is if they quote you and say you said something you didn't say. But the problem here is ... they do quote a lot of what I've said. And I read it, and I found myself just sitting there nodding.
35:00 They're encouraging people to contact us all via our councillor emails. And all of them are sending... getting people to send, you know, emails and messages to us, which I think is a form of encouraging harassment.
37:40 "Councillor Adderley, if this report has misunderstood you, please tell us, and we will correct the record straight away." That's nice of you, isn't it? ... I might tell them, "You haven't got all of my best bits."
From an automatic transcript of the livestream, checked against what is on screen where this site is read out; each time opens the video at that moment.
In the news
A news story naming Cllr Mark Adderley
- Greens for Palestine, with Cllr Mark Adderley: the Green Party "doesn't have a 'Friends of Israel' group", so "perhaps that's why we're the only party willing to oppose genocide"Posted by Greens for Palestine and Cllr Mark Adderley on Instagram, as an image of their post on X
What they put in writing
“We are Green councillors who support the "Zionism is Racism" motion passed at the Green Party conference on 4th October 2026.”
Cllr Mark Adderley, Green Party councillor for Crystal Palace and Upper Norwood ward, Croydon, backed the motion in public, as Open letter from Green councillors reported on 19 October 2026. Signed the open letter of Green councillors who support the motion, shared online and in the motion's WhatsApp group on 19 October 2026. Their words are quoted exactly from that report.
Cllr Adderley: if this report has misunderstood you, tell us and we will correct the record straight away.
Is Zionism racism? No.
Why Cllr Adderley is wrong
What Cllr Adderley said, and why it is wrong
The open letter is answered line by line on the main site, with every claim in it set against the motion's own text and the public record: the open letter, answered.
Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find, including many who are fierce critics of Israeli governments.
The letter's signatories say the motion has been described in ways they do not recognise. The motion is 22 pages long and anyone can read it. It declares Zionism racism, to be treated "as any other form of racism"; commits the party to "oppose and campaign against" it; rejects both the IHRA definition of antisemitism and the Jerusalem Declaration; and calls for "a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine". The description that fits is the one in its own words.
The working definition of antisemitism of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, adopted by the UK Government, gives as an example "denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor".
In 1975 the United Nations General Assembly declared that "Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination". In 1991 it revoked that, by 111 votes to 25. The Green Party has brought back the line the world withdrew, and one of its own councillors has backed it in public.
What the motion's authors really sayThe motion, line by line
Councillors of every other party are saying the opposite
Councillors and MPs of every party in England and Wales are putting their names to one sentence: Zionism is not racism. See who has signed, or ask your own councillors and MP to sign.