These councillors say Zionism is racism
Racist

The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist. Why

← All the councillors

Cllr Neil Buttle

Would not reject it

Green Party councillor

Cllr Neil Buttle

Tideswell ward, Derbyshire Dales

Asked to reject the motion, they would not. Reported saying: “We have essentially said that none of us would have voted for it but that we are not going to go against Green policy, because we are absolutely against genocide. I think Labour are trying to make it look like we are split on this and I don't think we are really. It has never been raised with me when I am knocking on the doors. It is normally about bins and public toilets, and I agree with them, the public toilets situation needs tackling.”

Party
Green Party
Reported
3 November 2026

Tell them why it’s wrongWhy Zionism is not racismThe councillors who backed the motion

In the news

A news story naming Cllr Neil Buttle

  1. Derbyshire Dales' Green leader: "none of us would have voted for it but we are not going to go against Green policy". And: "Let's get back to tackling public toilets"Derbyshire Times

Their refusal, in writing

“We have essentially said that none of us would have voted for it but that we are not going to go against Green policy, because we are absolutely against genocide. I think Labour are trying to make it look like we are split on this and I don't think we are really. It has never been raised with me when I am knocking on the doors. It is normally about bins and public toilets, and I agree with them, the public toilets situation needs tackling.”

Cllr Neil Buttle, Green Party councillor for Tideswell ward, Derbyshire Dales, was asked to reject the motion and would not, as Derbyshire Times reported on 3 November 2026. As leader of the Green group on Derbyshire Dales District Council, to the Derbyshire Times, after Labour ended the progressive alliance: the group will not reject the motion. Their words are quoted exactly from that report.

Cllr Buttle: if this report has misunderstood you, tell us and we will correct the record straight away.

Is Zionism racism? No.

Why Zionism is not racism

What Cllr Buttle said, and why it is wrong

Cllr Buttle says none of the group would have voted for the motion, and that the group will not say so. Those two things do not sit together. If nobody in the Derbyshire Dales Green group would have voted for it, rejecting it costs one sentence. The Green group on East Hertfordshire Council said exactly that, "The Green group at East Herts Council does not support the motion", and kept its administration. Derbyshire Dales would not, and lost its alliance.

"Because we are absolutely against genocide" answers a question nobody asked. The motion is not about a war. It declares that Zionism, the belief that the Jewish people have a homeland, is racism, to be "treated as any other form of racism". Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find, including many who are fierce critics of Israeli governments.

That it is never raised on the doorstep is no answer either. Jewish residents are few in the Derbyshire Dales. Whether a party may call a small minority racists for a belief about their own people is not a question settled by how seldom they are met while canvassing about bins.

The working definition of antisemitism of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, adopted by the UK Government, gives as an example "denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor".

In 1975 the United Nations General Assembly declared that "Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination". In 1991 it revoked that, by 111 votes to 25. The Green Party has brought back the line the world withdrew, and an elected councillor of another party, asked to say in one sentence that Zionism is not racism, has refused in writing.

What the motion's authors really sayThe motion, line by line

Councillors of every other party are saying the opposite

Councillors and MPs of every party in England and Wales are putting their names to one sentence: Zionism is not racism. See who has signed, or ask your own councillors and MP to sign.