These councillors say Zionism is racism
Racist

The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist. Why

← All the councillors

Cllr Netty Shepherd

Would not reject it

Green Party councillor

Cllr Netty Shepherd

Hayling East ward, Havant

Asked to reject the motion, they would not. Reported saying: “I reject the accusation that the motion is antisemitic and that therefore we the Green party are antisemitic. ... I cannot and will not comply with this request.”

Party
Green Party
Reported
27 October 2026

Tell them why it’s wrongWhy Zionism is not racismThe councillors who backed the motion

The Green group leader on video, 3 November 2026

"There have been claims that the Green Party is anti-Semitic. I absolutely reject that." Asked to say Zionism is not racism, Cllr Shepherd talks about the capital programme

The day after Labour ended Havant Borough Council's coalition over the motion, Cllr Netty Shepherd, leader of the council's Green group, posted this video on Facebook outside the council's offices. Here it is in full, with a transcript, and what is wrong with it.

Cllr Netty Shepherd, on Facebook, 3 November 2026 (1 min 25 s). Shown in full for reporting and comment.

What the councillor says, and what is wrong with it

  1. "I absolutely reject that"

    Nobody asked Cllr Shepherd to accept that the Green Party is antisemitic. Labour asked the Green group, on 15 October, for a "clear and unambiguous" rejection of the "Zionism is Racism" motion. Cllr Shepherd's written answer, as Local Government Chronicle reported on 27 October, was: "I reject the accusation that the motion is antisemitic and that therefore we the Green party are antisemitic," and: "I cannot and will not comply with this request." Rejecting the accusation is not rejecting the motion. The motion declares the Green Party "an anti-Zionist party" and calls for "a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine". The Prime Minister called it antisemitic on the record on 14 October; the Board of Deputies of British Jews resolved by 118 votes to 1 that the party had become a racist party; the Equality and Human Rights Commission has written to the party. Cllr Shepherd has still not said the one sentence asked for: that Zionism is not racism.

  2. "Will not keep anyone in Palestine safe"

    The question put to Havant's Green group was not about Palestine. It was about the Jewish residents of Havant, whose belief that Jews have a homeland the motion calls racism. Cllr Shepherd answers a question about Gaza that nobody asked, and leaves the one that was asked unanswered. Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people have a homeland; nine in ten British Jews hold it. The motion the Green group will not reject calls that belief racism. That is what Labour's letter said it could not share power with.

  3. "The Labour Party has chosen to stop us in our tracks"

    Labour's chair wrote to every Labour council group on 15 October and set 25 October as the date. Havant's Green group had three weeks, and its leader's answer was "I cannot and will not comply". On 2 November Labour left its arrangements on eleven councils, Havant among them, and the Labour Party's chair said: "we cannot work with any party that supports it, at any level of government." The coalition ended because the Green group chose the motion over the coalition. The video does not say so.

  4. Town centres, the arts, young people

    Most of the video is about Havant's capital programme and what the Green councillors have delivered. In this campaign's view, a regeneration scheme is not an answer to whether Zionism is racism, and the councillor knows what the question is, because the councillor wrote the refusal to answer it. Cllr Shepherd's page records that refusal, in the councillor's own words, until the Green group says in public that Zionism is not racism.

Read the transcript

An automatic transcript of the video, corrected for the spelling of Labour and of Havant, with nothing else changed. The times are approximate, and the video is above so you can check every word against it.

0:00 Yesterday afternoon the Labour Party dissolved the coalition and sacked the Greens from cabinet. But I want to set the record straight: there have been claims that the Green Party is anti-Semitic. I absolutely reject that.

0:13 The Labour Party's statement mentioned the rights of Jews and Palestinians to have a safe and secure homeland. And this letter that the Labour Party have sent me, and the actions of the local Labour Party, will not keep anyone in Palestine safe today, or tomorrow.

0:29 But what it will do is change things for local residents here in Havant borough, because now we no longer have a coalition. We have been working together, the three parties and an independent, to actually produce the most ambitious capital programme we have ever had in the borough. Town centre regeneration, supporting our arts, supporting our young people into employment: these are all brilliant things that should have been happening for decades but haven't been. So now we are finally moving forward in the right direction.

1:00 The Labour Party have chosen to stop us in our tracks. They don't have the support to win votes to get the next budget through without the Green Party. I'm still going to be delivering for residents, and so will my colleagues in the Green Party. So I want to thank my colleagues in the Labour Party and the Lib Dems, and our independent councillor, Paul Gray, for the support they've given the Green Party over the last few years. But now we're going to carry on working; it doesn't stop.

In the news

A news story naming Cllr Netty Shepherd

  1. At least three Green groups do not reject the motion after Labour's ultimatum: Derbyshire Dales, Havant and SheffieldLocal Government Chronicle

Their refusal, in writing

“I reject the accusation that the motion is antisemitic and that therefore we the Green party are antisemitic. ... I cannot and will not comply with this request.”

Cllr Netty Shepherd, Green Party councillor for Hayling East ward, Havant, was asked to reject the motion and would not, as Local Government Chronicle reported on 27 October 2026. Answering Labour's request that the Green group reject the motion, as Local Government Chronicle reported on 27 October 2026. On 3 November, the day after Labour ended Havant's coalition, Cllr Shepherd said on video: "there have been claims that the Green Party is anti-Semitic. I absolutely reject that." The video is on this page. Their words are quoted exactly from that report.

Cllr Shepherd: if this report has misunderstood you, tell us and we will correct the record straight away.

Is Zionism racism? No.

Why Zionism is not racism

What Cllr Shepherd said, and why it is wrong

Rejecting an accusation is not answering it. The Prime Minister called the motion antisemitic, on the record. The Board of Deputies of British Jews, the elected body of the community the motion describes, resolved by 118 votes to 1 that the Green Party "has, by adopting an antisemitic platform, become a racist party". The working definition of antisemitism adopted by the UK Government gives as an example "denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor".

Zionism is the belief that the Jewish people, like the French, the Irish or the Palestinians, have the right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. Nine in ten British Jews see Israel as the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, surveys find, including many who are fierce critics of Israeli governments.

The request Cllr Shepherd "cannot and will not comply with" was to say that the motion is wrong. Labour ended Havant's coalition over that refusal. Nobody asked Cllr Shepherd to stop criticising an Israeli government; Zionists criticise them too. The only thing asked for was one sentence about the Jewish residents of Havant, and it was refused.

The working definition of antisemitism of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, adopted by the UK Government, gives as an example "denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor".

In 1975 the United Nations General Assembly declared that "Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination". In 1991 it revoked that, by 111 votes to 25. The Green Party has brought back the line the world withdrew, and an elected councillor of another party, asked to say in one sentence that Zionism is not racism, has refused in writing.

What the motion's authors really sayThe motion, line by line

Councillors of every other party are saying the opposite

Councillors and MPs of every party in England and Wales are putting their names to one sentence: Zionism is not racism. See who has signed, or ask your own councillors and MP to sign.