These councillors say Zionism is racism
Tell them
Racist

The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist. Why

Green Party pre-conference workshop, "A3 Zionism is Racism", Microsoft Teams, 22 September 2026

The party's own workshop, line by line

Twelve days before the vote, the Green Party's Standing Orders Committee ran its official workshop on the motion for members: an hour on Teams, the only motion in the party's timetable given a slot to itself. The proposer did not attend. In her place a member introduced it; a sitting Green councillor chaired; a Jewish member proposed a safeguard for Jewish members; and the room, in a straw poll, voted the safeguard down 24 to 67 and the motion through 75 to 26. We have listened to every minute of a recording. Here is what was said, quoted exactly with the time, and why it is wrong.

64
minutes, every one listened to
24 to 67
the straw poll against protecting Jewish members' synagogue membership
0
of the hard questions answered
2
sitting Green councillors who took part

Criticising Israeli governments, the occupation or the conduct of the war in Gaza is not antisemitism, and nothing on this page says it is. Members who asked questions are named only where they introduced themselves; the two sitting councillors are on this site's lists already. What follows is about what the motion's own side said it means, who it counts as a racist, and what happened when Jewish members asked to be protected from it.

  1. Asked whether people who oppose the motion, support two states, or belong to Jewish bodies that call themselves Zionist would be "Zionist and therefore racist" under it, the member introducing the motion answered: "if what you believe falls in line with that, then perhaps you are." The chair confirmed that the written definition binds the party.

  2. A Jewish member proposed an amendment to protect Jewish members' membership of synagogues, youth movements and prayer groups, most of which call themselves Zionist. Members called the safeguard "incredibly dangerous". The straw poll rejected it, 24 to 67. He told the meeting that when his brother, "a very publicly anti-Zionist Jew", had spoken earlier, "someone immediately shouted Zionist".

  3. The motion was introduced as being about "Gaza, the world's largest concentration camp", "the ethnic cleansing of Lebanon, of Syria, the war on Iran", and overturning the ban on Palestine Action. A Green county councillor asked what role armed force plays in "the removal of Israel as an independent state". Another member asked what happens to the Jews of Israel. Nobody answered either.

What the motion does, in its own side's words

3 quotations

What they say

The motion seeks to declare the Green Party an anti-Zionist party. The motion seeks the Green Party to take the stance of a single Palestinian state, with equal rights for all and the right of return for all Palestinians in the global diaspora. The motion seeks to view Zionism as any other form of racism. The motion seeks to support the release of Palestinian prisoners of conscience, including Marwan Barghouti. The motion seeks to upturn the proscription of Palestine Action, and supports political prisoners of the Palestine Action movement, who are currently in British prisons.

The member who introduced the motion for its absent proposer, named by the chair as Ash, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 7:36 to 8:25)

What is wrong with it

Five things, said plainly to the party's members by the person entrusted with the motion for the evening: an anti-Zionist party; one state in place of Israel; the belief that Israel should exist "as any other form of racism"; Marwan Barghouti, convicted of five murders, a prisoner of conscience; and support for members of Palestine Action, proscribed under the Terrorism Act 2000 since 5 July 2025, "who are currently in British prisons". This is the motion as its own side explained it, in the party's own procedure, twelve days before the party passed it.

What they say

We judge Zionism by what it is in reality, not what it could be in theory. ... When we speak of Zionism, we speak of Gaza, the world's largest concentration camp ... We speak of the gang rape and murder of a young Bedouin girl in the Negev by IDF soldiers ... And we speak of the ethnic cleansing of Lebanon, of Syria, the war on Iran, and of course, the genocide unfolding in Gaza before our very eyes. ... [The chair:] Ash, I'm so sorry, Ash, could you just say what your motion will do? Because what you're essentially doing is arguing this case.

The member who introduced the motion for its absent proposer, named by the chair as Ash, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 5:52 to 7:18, and the chair at 7:19)

What is wrong with it

This is how the motion was introduced to the party's members: not with its text but with a list that runs from 1948 to Iran, by way of a Holocaust word for Gaza and an unsourced allegation of gang rape by named armed forces. Lebanon, Syria and Iran are three sovereign states; folding them into "when we speak of Zionism" makes the motion an indictment of everything Israel has ever done anywhere, which is not what a definition of an ideology looks like. The chair, a sitting Green councillor, stopped it and asked for the motion instead.

"Concentration camp" for Gaza is the Holocaust turned on the Jews. "Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis" is an example of antisemitism in the definition adopted by the UK Government and most councils, which the motion as drafted rejected.

What they say

The single democratic Palestinian state with equal rights for all and Jerusalem as its capital, that is included in the motion because it makes logical sense. The Green Party opposes settler colonialism. Israel is a settler colony. We should be cogent in our policy. Our policy should make sense. We cannot oppose settler colonialism anywhere else in the world and then seemingly support it in one particular place.

The member who introduced the motion for its absent proposer, named by the chair as Ash, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 1:00:44 to 1:01:16)

What is wrong with it

The syllogism the party was given for ending a member state of the United Nations: Israel is a colony, so it must go. Colonists have a mother country to go home to. More than half of Israel's Jews descend from the Jews of the Middle East and North Africa, some 850,000 of whom were driven out of Iraq, Yemen, Egypt, Libya, Syria and elsewhere after 1948, and the rest from a Europe that had just murdered six million of them. Nobody at the workshop said where seven million people go, or what "logical sense" looks like for them. See the next section.

Who counts as a racist

3 quotations

What they say

Would you say that somebody who opposes this motion would be a Zionist and therefore a racist? ... I want to know about opposers of the motion, people who support a two-state solution, people who are members of bodies that describe themselves as Zionist. ... Basically I want to know whether they'd be considered Zionist by this motion.

Joshua, of Leeds Green Party, the first member to speak, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 10:37 to 12:11)

What is wrong with it

The question the party has never answered in public, put to it in its own procedure by a member who said he supports "most of what's in the motion, including declaring the Green Party an anti-Zionist party". Most British Jews say Israel should exist; the synagogue bodies most of them belong to call themselves Zionist. Does the motion make them racists? The answer is below.

What they say

We're not voting on my ideology. We're voting on the text that's in the motion. ... Zionism is defined as a political ideology which called for the creation, and now it exists, the continuity of an ethno-nationalist Jewish state in historic Palestine ... to the exclusion or domination of non-Jewish population. So if what you believe falls in line with that, then perhaps you are. If what you believe doesn't fall in line with that, perhaps you're not. It's not up for me to decide. ... Sure, there are lots of, I guess, theoretical versions of Zionism. I would say the world has never seen those theoretical versions of Zionism manifest. The version of Zionism that we see manifest is in occupied Palestine itself.

The member who introduced the motion for its absent proposer, named by the chair as Ash, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 14:35 to 15:25, and 15:46 to 16:25)

What is wrong with it

Asked directly whether a Jewish Green who supports two states, or belongs to a synagogue body that calls itself Zionist, is a racist under the motion, the motion's advocate would not say no. "Perhaps you are." And the other definitions of Zionism, the ones most British Jews actually hold, are "theoretical" and have "never" existed: so the motion's definition is the only one that counts, and whoever it fits is a racist.

The party's line since the vote has been that the motion is about an ideology, not about Jews. Its own advocate, in its own workshop, could not keep the two apart for one answer.

What they say

The individual interpretations of one person or the other aren't particularly relevant. If the motion is down in writing, then the Green Party is bound by [it], whatever an individual interprets it. ... It's not for you to decide, but you are meant to be explaining the motion. So please, you know, stick to your, stick to the motion.

Cllr Geraldine Coggins (Trafford), who chaired, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 11:08 to 11:29, and 15:28 to 15:45)

What is wrong with it

The chair was right, and that is the point. The party is bound by the written definition, and the written definition is the one read out above: an "ethno-nationalist Jewish state ... to the exclusion or domination" of others. The motion then orders that Zionism "be treated as any other form of racism" by the party's Anti-Racism Policy Working Group. What one member thinks is not relevant; what the text does to Jewish members is.

The safeguard for Jewish members, and the vote on it

4 quotations

What they say

This amendment is intended to safeguard Jewish members, practicing Jewish members and their ability to be members of institutions. ... What this motion is asking us to do is to proscribe an ideology, something that the party hasn't done before ... using a definition that's not going to be recognized by the vast majority of people who claim to adhere to that ideology. Unfortunately, at the current time, the majority of Jewish institutions and the majority of Jews in the UK define themselves as Zionist, again, rejecting the definition that this motion has put forward. This includes youth movements, synagogues, prayer groups. I, as a practicing Jew ... this amendment is intended to make absolutely crystal clear that we're against religious discrimination, direct and indirect.

Sam, of Oxford Green Party, who proposed amendment 3, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 50:39 to 52:03)

What is wrong with it

A Jewish member of the party, in the party's own procedure, asked for one thing: that belonging to a synagogue, a Jewish youth movement or a prayer group should not be incompatible with being a Green. That is all the amendment did. It did not touch the motion's view of Israel. It would have left the party anti-Zionist. It asked only that Jewish religious life not be treated as racism by default.

What they say

I'm trying to figure out where in the motion there's actually anything about disciplining ... and why you're singling out specifically Jewish members as opposed to others, because I think there's also Christian Zionist churches ... I'm a bit concerned that this particular amendment is conflating Judaism with Zionism. ... I think it's an incredibly dangerous thing when we keep conflating the Jewish community, a religious group, with what is a political ideology ... I think Amendment 3 is incredibly dangerous.

Two members speaking against amendment 3, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 53:25 to 54:08, and 55:46 to 56:16)

What is wrong with it

The motion is "about an ideology, not Jews", so a safeguard for Jews is the dangerous thing. But the motion does discipline: it orders that Zionism "be treated as any other form of racism" and "implemented by the Anti-Racism Policy Working Group". And it was the party, not the amendment, that put synagogues in the frame: at Greens for Palestine's own stream for the motion six weeks earlier, the proposer called synagogues "a front to commit war crimes" and said "we should put pressure on those spaces". The amendment answered that. The room called the answer dangerous.

What they say

The separation between Zionism and Judaism is not clear ... When someone says they're being Zionist, because the definition isn't the same as the one used by this motion, it could mean they're just as innocent, or worse, it could mean they've gone to a protest for Gaza. ... We saw in this meeting, right at the start, my brother Joshua spoke, someone immediately shouted Zionist. He's a very publicly anti-Zionist Jew, had been so for a long time, and yet still gets told with this brush because of his Judaism. This is why we need the amendment. ... [If] the Green Party members vote down the idea that synagogue membership should be protected and should be compatible with Green Party identity, [that] would be terrible and a terrible signal to send to Jewish members.

Sam, of Oxford Green Party, who proposed amendment 3, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 57:03 to 58:30)

What is wrong with it

At the party's own meeting, by this account, "Zionist" was shouted at a Jewish member the moment he spoke, a member who opposes Zionism and said so. That is the word used as a slur for being Jewish, in the room where the party was deciding whether to make it a category of racism. The chair did not pick it up and nobody on the recording disputes it.

He said what the signal would be if the safeguard were voted down. Then it was.

What they say

Amendment one was 24 for, 72 against, amendment two was 18 for, 68 against. ... So, amendment three, 24 for and 67 against. ... [The substantive motion:] I think it was seventy-five. ... [Against:] Twenty-six, I believe.

Cllr Geraldine Coggins (Trafford), who chaired, giving the straw polls, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 52:31 to 52:38, 1:01:21, and 1:02:48 to 1:03:55)

What is wrong with it

Informal, by hands on Teams, counted by volunteers, taken while people were still speaking: about a hundred members, three to one for the motion unamended. The amendment to protect synagogue membership lost 24 to 67. Twelve days later the party's leader tried an amendment to the same end at conference, and it was blocked. The party was told, twice, by a Jewish member and by its own leader, what the motion would do to Jewish members. It passed the motion anyway.

The questions nobody answered

3 quotations

What they say

My reading of the motion suggests that they're looking for the removal of Israel as an independent state. So what role does armed force play in that? Because it seems to be fairly nebulous in the motion.

Cllr Craig Horrocks, Stroud District Green Party, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 18:27 to 18:41)

What is wrong with it

A sitting Green county councillor reads the motion as "the removal of Israel as an independent state", and asks how. The motion affirms Palestinian "struggle ... by all available means", and its briefing paper says "including armed struggle"; at Greens for Palestine's stream for it, the invited speakers said "we will use arms" whatever the law says. Nobody at the workshop answered him. The chair deferred the proposer's replies "towards the end", and at the end the question was not among those he chose to answer.

What they say

Does it offer assurances as to what happens to the Jewish population in what's currently called Israel, in the transition to a single Palestinian state? ... The Palestine Center for Policy and Survey Research did an opinion poll in August, and it found that there was not a majority support for a one-state solution. ... And the second question, what difference will the motion make to Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank, apart from the Palestinian prisoners?

A member, and Vivian Lichtenstein of West Central London Green Party, who chairs Jewish Greens, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 21:31 to 21:46, and 22:53 to 23:26)

What is wrong with it

Seven million Jews live in Israel. What happens to them in "the transition" was asked, in the party's own workshop, and not answered. Whether Palestinians themselves want the motion's one state was asked, with the polling, and not answered. What the motion does for anyone in Gaza was asked, and not answered. The only answer given, an hour later, was that one state "makes logical sense".

What they say

Sorry, sorry, do I not get to respond to any of the questions? ... [The chair:] We will try and get you a response towards the end. ... I really want to hear Ash's, give Ash a chance to respond ... And at the same time, while people are raising their hands in support of amendment three, can Ash come back and respond.

The member who introduced the motion for its absent proposer, named by the chair as Ash, and the chair, at the Green Party's pre-conference workshop on the motion, 22 September 2026 (transcript of the recording, 24:41 to 24:55, and 58:32 to 59:09)

What is wrong with it

The motion's advocate was given his reply time while the hands were being counted on the amendment to protect Jewish members, and used it to say that the party already proscribes racism as an ideology, so this "simply brings Zionism in line", and that one state is logical. Not armed force, not the Jews of Israel, not whether two-staters are racists. The party's own explanatory session on the motion ended with the motion unexplained on every point that matters to the people it is about.

Taken together

What it adds up to

This was not a fringe meeting or a campaign group's stream. It was the Green Party's own procedure, chaired by a sitting Green councillor, with the Standing Orders Committee in the room, twelve days before the vote. In it, the motion's advocate told a Jewish member that under the motion's definition "perhaps you are" a racist; a Jewish member asked that belonging to a synagogue not make him one, and three members in four said no; and the questions of what happens to Israel's Jews, and by what force, were asked and left in silence.

Zionism is not racism. Green councillors can say so by signing the pledge; councillors and MPs of every other party, by adding their name.

Green councillors: sign the pledge Other councillors and MPs: add your name

Quotations are from a timestamped transcript of an audio recording of the Green Party's "Pre-conference workshop on Motion A3 "Zionism is Racism"", Microsoft Teams, 22 September 2026, with the time in the recording. They are quoted for criticism and review. The straw polls were informal and the counts were contested on the night; they are given as the chair announced them.