These councillors say Zionism is racism
Racist

The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist. Why

← The evidence file

Cllr Brenda Puech

Evidence file

Green Party

Cllr Brenda Puech

London Fields ward, London Borough of Hackney

Brenda Puech is a Green Party councillor for London Fields ward on the London Borough of Hackney. Brenda Puech is listed as a signatory of the open letter of 19 October 2026 by Green councillors supporting the motion. This page records 13 items: 10 concerning criticism of Israel or related activism; 1 concerning the motion; 2 of context or mitigating statements.

  • B Criticism of Israel or related activism10Criticism of Israel or related activism
  • C Statement on the motion1Statement on the motion
  • D Context and mitigating statements2Context and mitigating statements

Their page: why they are wrongThe itemsHow this file was made

The items, in their own words

Each item gives the date, the platform, the words as published, the source, and a screenshot where one was taken. Category labels are this file's assessment, not findings of any authority.

B Criticism of Israel or related activism Criticism of Israel or related activism 10

Criticism of Israel or related activism that does not clearly fit an IHRA example. Claims about a "Zionist" or pro-Israel lobby, hostile statements about "Zionists" or Israelis rather than Jews, calls for a single state, statements about a right to resist, and opposition to a proscription without a statement of support are placed here.

B Criticism of Israel or related activism21 October 2023 · InstagramVerified against the source

From the river to the sea...........

Caption on a photo of her holding a Palestinian flag at a London march; in a comment on the post she wrote 'Lots of people in UK against the disproportionate retribution against Palestinian civilians in the revenge for Hamas atrocities.'

Source

Screenshot of the post, 21 October 2023, Instagram
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism27 October 2023 · InstagramVerified against the source

Look who’s home is visible across the park. From the river to the sea….

Caption on a photo of a home displaying a Palestinian flag and a 'Gaza' sign.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 27 October 2023, Instagram
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism15 November 2023 · InstagramVerified against the source

It is not illegal to resist an illegal occupation.

Caption on a photo of a protest placard reading 'FACT: PALESTINE HAS THE RIGHT TO RESIST ILLEGAL OCCUPATION INC. THROUGH ARMED STRUGGLE (UN RES 37/43)'.

Why this category: A general statement about resistance, recorded as B.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 15 November 2023, Instagram
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism17 May 2025 · BlueskyVerified against the source

#NakbaDay Huge solidarity demonstrated by hundreds of thousands in London today. #StopTheGenocide

Bluesky post about the Nakba Day march in London in May 2025, before her election in May 2026.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 17 May 2025, Bluesky
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism14 June 2025 · XVerified against the source

Love this. Israel is NOT a Jewish state please!

Post with a photo and video of Haredi anti-Zionist protesters in Parliament Square.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 14 June 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism28 June 2025 · XVerified against the source

Well said @sianberry! Proscribing Palestine Action is playing into hands of those complicit in terrorising and massacring Palestinians.

Quote-post of Sian Berry, posted on 28 June 2025, before Palestine Action's proscription took effect on 5 July 2025.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 28 June 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism21 February 2026 · BlueskyVerified against the source

Wow! Trump's "Board of Peace" is going to build a massive 5,000-person military base in Gaza, over 350 acres. It will be ringed by 26 armored watch towers, a small arms range, bunkers, huge warehouse for military equipment & will be encircled with barbed wire! They want Gaza to be a massive prison.

Bluesky post about a reported plan for a military base in Gaza.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 21 February 2026, Bluesky
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism19 August 2026 · XVerified against the source

@AndyBurnham recently received over £164,000 from Lord Sainsbury a major financial donor associated with @_LFI Labour Friends of Israel. Don't hold your breath about @UKLabour holding Israel to account.

Reply to a BBC Politics post about donations received by Andy Burnham.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 19 August 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism21 October 2026 · XVerified against the source

@RuthMayorcas But the Palestinians had nothing to do with the persecution of Jews, so why are THEY being made to pay by having their land, homes and lives forcibly taken away so that Jews (and Christian Zionists) can have a 'safe' homeland?

Reply to Ruth Mayorcas during the October 2026 debate about the Green Party motion.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 21 October 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activismabout 8 June 2026 · XVerified against the source

A blank space on @HackneyCouncil website where my mugshot used to be! Fortunately I can still publicise my surgery times, though photo below is too offensive to publish.

Posted after Hackney Council removed her official portrait, in which she wore a keffiyeh, following a complaint by UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI); Hackney Citizen also reports she reposted another user's comment calling for UKLFI to be proscribed.

Source

C Statement on the motion Statement on the motion 1

Statements about, or formal support for, the motion.

C Statement on the motion19 October 2026 · Open letter of Green councillors (copy published by the Campaign for Zionism Is Not Racism)Second-hand report

We are Green councillors who support the "Zionism is Racism" motion passed at the Green Party conference on 4th October 2026.

Opening sentence of a collective open letter backing the Green Party conference motion, shared online and in the motion's WhatsApp group as images, on which the councillor is listed as "Brenda Puech, London Fields, Hackney".

Source

D Context and mitigating statements Context and mitigating statements 2

Context and mitigating statements: condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, included for every councillor where found.

D Context and mitigating statements6 October 2025 · XVerified against the source

@RuthMayorcas I have huge sympathy for Jewish communities whose lives and safety are threatened (and taken) by deranged attackers, but I do not think you can blame the Palestine Solidarity marches which are always peaceful, and joined by many concerned Jewish people.

Reply to Ruth Mayorcas after the Heaton Park synagogue attack in October 2025.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 6 October 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements21 October 2025 · XVerified against the source

20 powerful reasons for Hamas to give up arms. Worth going through each one.

Quote-post of a thread arguing that Hamas should disarm.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 21 October 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.

How this file was made

  • This file covers councillors listed on zionismisracism.co.uk as backing the motion passed at the Green Party conference on 4 October 2026. A councillor appears here only where at least one item about them meets the standards below.
  • Items come from the councillors' own public social media posts and videos, council records, election records, party websites and news reports, from 7 October 2023 onwards. Spoken words in videos were transcribed and checked against the recording.
  • Every item was checked against its source on 23 October 2026: social media posts against the live post or a screenshot of it, articles and documents against the published page, and spoken words against the recording.
  • Quotes are verbatim, including the original spelling. Where only a reporter's paraphrase exists this is stated, and paraphrases are not placed in categories A, E or F.
  • Reposts are included only where the act of sharing is itself the point, and are labelled as reposts.
  • Mitigating statements, such as condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, are included for every councillor where found.
  • The absence of an item means none was found in this search, not that none exists.

The categories

  • A Meets an IHRA example Meets an IHRA example. Words that clearly fit a named example in the IHRA working definition of antisemitism. The example is stated on each item. Explicit comparisons of Israel, Israelis or Zionism with Nazism or the Holocaust, statements naming Jews, and classic antisemitic images used to describe Israel are placed here.
  • E Support for a proscribed organisation Support for a proscribed organisation. An express statement of support for an organisation proscribed under the Terrorism Act 2000, or praise of an attack on civilians. Each item states whether it was made before or after the organisation was proscribed. Palestine Action was proscribed on 5 July 2025; a further appeal is before the Supreme Court.
  • F Political affiliation Political affiliation. Membership of, candidacy for, or speaking at events of communist, Marxist-Leninist or revolutionary political groups. These are lawful affiliations and are recorded as facts.
  • B Criticism of Israel or related activism Criticism of Israel or related activism. Criticism of Israel or related activism that does not clearly fit an IHRA example. Claims about a "Zionist" or pro-Israel lobby, hostile statements about "Zionists" or Israelis rather than Jews, calls for a single state, statements about a right to resist, and opposition to a proscription without a statement of support are placed here.
  • C Statement on the motion Statement on the motion. Statements about, or formal support for, the motion.
  • D Context and mitigating statements Context and mitigating statements. Context and mitigating statements: condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, included for every councillor where found.

Fairness and the law

  • Category labels are this file's assessment against the IHRA examples, not findings of any authority.
  • Where a council has investigated a complaint about an item, the outcome is recorded with the item.
  • Claims that newspapers have retracted are not repeated in this edition.
  • Items concerning anyone who may face active criminal proceedings, or criminal allegations against third parties, are not included.
  • Each councillor with an item in category A or E is invited to respond before those items are published, and any response is added to their page.

Every item can be checked at its source. If anything here is wrong, or if you are the councillor and want to respond, write to hello@zionismisracism.co.uk: a correction goes up the day it is confirmed, and a response is added to the page in full.

Why Zionism is not racism

Cllr Brenda Puech's page on this site sets out what they put their name to and why it is wrong. The case, line by line, is on the main site: Is Zionism racism? and the motion, line by line.