These councillors say Zionism is racism
Racist

The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist. Why

← The evidence file

Cllr Kamel Hawwash

Evidence file

Green Party

Cllr Kamel Hawwash

Stirchley ward, Birmingham City Council

Kamel Hawwash is a Green Party councillor for Stirchley ward on Birmingham City Council. Kamel Hawwash is named in a printed list of the motion's supporters; because the list gives names only, that entry is not reproduced here. This page records 22 items: 17 concerning criticism of Israel or related activism; 5 of context or mitigating statements.

  • B Criticism of Israel or related activism17Criticism of Israel or related activism
  • D Context and mitigating statements5Context and mitigating statements

Their page: why they are wrongThe itemsHow this file was made

The items, in their own words

Each item gives the date, the platform, the words as published, the source, and a screenshot where one was taken. Category labels are this file's assessment, not findings of any authority.

B Criticism of Israel or related activism Criticism of Israel or related activism 17

Criticism of Israel or related activism that does not clearly fit an IHRA example. Claims about a "Zionist" or pro-Israel lobby, hostile statements about "Zionists" or Israelis rather than Jews, calls for a single state, statements about a right to resist, and opposition to a proscription without a statement of support are placed here.

B Criticism of Israel or related activism20 November 2023 · XVerified against the source

الله يشفيه ويعافيه ويلطف بأهلنا في فلسطين. الخزي والعار لكل من يقف مع دولة الارهاب والعنصرية والاحتلال

Arabic reply to another user's post about an injured person in Gaza; an unofficial translation reads: 'May God heal him and be gentle with our people in Palestine. Shame and disgrace on everyone who stands with the state of terror, racism and occupation.'

Source

Screenshot of the post, 20 November 2023, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism4 December 2023 · XVerified against the source

I fear that is the reason and a prelude to expulsion to the Sinai. A truly racist criminal entity.

Reply in his own thread about an Israeli strike on the Palace of Justice in Gaza; 'entity' refers to Israel.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 4 December 2023, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism2 August 2024 · XVerified against the source

The number of those mourning the late Ismail Haniyeh, who was murdered in Tehran a couple of days ago, runs into millions around the world.

When the war criminal #Netanyahu passes away there will be very few mourning him.

#Israel has summoned the Turkish representative in Tel Aviv because the Turkish flag was flying at half mast.

It has also threatened Sheikh Ekrima Sabri who marked Haniyeh’s passing from #Alaqsa mosque.

Refers to Hamas political leader Ismail Haniyeh, who was killed in Tehran on 31 July 2024; Hamas has been proscribed in full in the UK since November 2021.

Why this category: Expresses sympathy at the death of Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh; does not express support for Hamas.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 2 August 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism22 February 2025 · InstagramVerified against the source

The kiss of death to the racist genocidal colonialist Zionist Israeli project by and IDF soldier.

Caption on footage of the 22 February 2025 Hamas hostage-release ceremony in Gaza, in which a released Israeli hostage is shown beside masked Hamas fighters.

Why this category: Mocking caption on footage of a Hamas hostage handover; does not express support for Hamas.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 22 February 2025, Instagram
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
Screenshot of the post, 22 February 2025, Instagram
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism31 March 2025 · XVerified against the source

The war ends if Israel brings the 50,000 dead Palestinians back to life.

Reply to an AIPAC post saying the war in Gaza would end if Hamas surrendered and freed the hostages.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 31 March 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism18 April 2025 · XVerified against the source

Alquds Ierusalem is Palestine’s capital. Get used to it.

Reply to the US Ambassador to Israel, the Western Wall account and the US President.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 18 April 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism29 April 2025 · InstagramVerified against the source

Terrorist murderous criminal genocidal #Israel is literally starving Palestinians especially children to death to pressure #HAMAS. It is a blight on humanity suppprted by America and the UK. @Keir_Starmer @DavidLammy are complicit in these horrendous crimes.

Caption on a post showing footage of an emaciated person's legs from an Al Jazeera broadcast.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 29 April 2025, Instagram
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism8 August 2025 · XVerified against the source

What action will you take if this monstrous evil entity expels 900,000 from Gaza city?

Reply to Keir Starmer's statement of 8 August 2025 on the Israeli government's decision to escalate its offensive in Gaza; 'entity' refers to Israel.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 8 August 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism11 August 2025 · InstagramVerified against the source

Israel is the nost criminal state of he 21st century https://kamelhawwash.com/2025/08/11/israel-is-the-nost-criminal-state-of-he-21st-century/

Instagram post linking his blog article of the same title.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 11 August 2025, Instagram
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism27 November 2025 · Instagram (video)Verified against the source

Priti Patel a disgrace. She has again visited #genocidal #terrorist state #Israel and lauded the genocidal entity as a democracy.

Caption on a video cross-posted from TikTok about a visit to Israel by Priti Patel MP.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 27 November 2025, Instagram (video)
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism31 December 2025 · InstagramVerified against the source

End #Zionism and dismantle the #Apartheid system in #Israel. Freedom for #Palestine. #Gaza https://vm.tiktok.com/ZNR6nX2Dy/

Instagram reel of him speaking.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 31 December 2025, Instagram
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism13 February 2026 · InstagramVerified against the source

Palestine Action wins legal challenge against UK terror ban https://kamelhawwash.com/2026/02/13/palestine-action-wins-legal-challenge-against-uk-terror-ban/

Instagram reel reporting the High Court ruling on Palestine Action's proscription in February 2026.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 13 February 2026, Instagram
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism19 May 2026 · InstagramVerified against the source

Lovely to meet holocaust survivor Stephen Kapos at the Palestinian Forum in Britain’s Nakba commemoration event last night. He has attended many times of the Palestinian protests in London as part of the Jewish block and is a great friend of the Palestinian people and justice. We sat next to each other at dinner and had a lovely conversation. Our previous photo featured in my campaign transition newsletter. I very much hope we can see him in Birmingham soon.

Instagram post about meeting Holocaust survivor Stephen Kapos at a Palestinian Forum in Britain Nakba event.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 19 May 2026, Instagram
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism7 October 2023 · Almagharibia TV (video, in Arabic)Second-hand report

The first thing they can do is keep these people and negotiate on many issues. ... Now we hear - this hasn't been confirmed by the Israeli side - that there are more than 35 Israelis, mostly soldiers ... The matter isn't just about the [Palestinian] prisoners; it's about lifting the siege and other things they can strive for.

Remarks in an Arabic-language interview given while the 7 October 2023 attack was under way, in The Jewish Chronicle's translation (30 July 2026) from the broadcaster's YouTube segment.

Source

B Criticism of Israel or related activism7 October 2023 · Almagharibia TV (video, in Arabic)Second-hand report

They use double standards, saying that Israel has the right to defend itself ... But where was this prime minister when the Palestinians were being killed? ... We shall not surrender.

Further remarks from the same 7 October 2023 interview, in The Jewish Chronicle's translation (30 July 2026).

Source

B Criticism of Israel or related activism19 June 2026 · The New ArabVerified against the source

what Israel has been doing has been war crimes, and that the UK should have stopped arming Israel ... people who came and created a state for other people and denied us our rights.

Interview with The New Arab published after his election to Birmingham City Council.

Source

B Criticism of Israel or related activismabout June 2026 · Campaign website (quoted in The Jewish Chronicle)Second-hand report

immediate recognition of Palestine - support the ICC and ICJ rulings for justice & peace

Listed as the first commitment on his campaign website, as reported by The Jewish Chronicle on 11 June 2026; the website itself is undated.

Source

D Context and mitigating statements Context and mitigating statements 5

Context and mitigating statements: condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, included for every councillor where found.

D Context and mitigating statements12 June 2026 · ITV News Central (reported by Novara Media)Verified against the source

Suggesting that these words were my own is a gross misrepresentation

The Daily Mail had reported that he praised the 7 October attack, based on a broadcaster's segment title, "10 days since Al-Aqsa Flood: Courage in the face of aggression"; the Mail removed the story and published a clarification that "the title wording was the broadcaster's, not his".

Source

D Context and mitigating statements15 October 2023 · XVerified against the source

I have decided to delete my tweet as the source I usually find reliable was not on this occasion. My focus as always is to relay accurate verifiable information on the #Palestine injustice.

We should all work to end #ApartheidIsrael’s war crimes being committed as I write. There is no excuse for this monstrous out.

Posted after he deleted an earlier post citing reports from 'Israel's channel 10' of mass desertion among Israeli soldiers, to which an X Community Note had added that no such channel exists.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 15 October 2023, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements4 November 2023 · XVerified against the source

Stop spreading misinformation @PiersUncensored there was none to of that at our protests. We want to save lives. #CeasefireNow

Reply to Piers Morgan, who had asked about Hamas flags and chants at protests; he was then chair of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 4 November 2023, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statementsJuly 2026 · Statement to The Jewish ChronicleVerified against the source

I have repeatedly said that I condemn attacks on civilians by individuals, groups or states

Response to The Jewish Chronicle's 30 July 2026 report on his 7 October 2023 interview, in which he also said he had "no truck whatsoever with terrorism or any proscribed group".

Source

D Context and mitigating statementsJune 2026 · ITV Central (quoted in The Jewish Chronicle)Second-hand report

I reject claims of antisemitism. ... I am fully committed to standing up for all Birmingham's diverse communities

Interview with ITV Central responding to criticism after his election, as reported by The Jewish Chronicle on 11 June 2026.

Source

How this file was made

  • This file covers councillors listed on zionismisracism.co.uk as backing the motion passed at the Green Party conference on 4 October 2026. A councillor appears here only where at least one item about them meets the standards below.
  • Items come from the councillors' own public social media posts and videos, council records, election records, party websites and news reports, from 7 October 2023 onwards. Spoken words in videos were transcribed and checked against the recording.
  • Every item was checked against its source on 23 October 2026: social media posts against the live post or a screenshot of it, articles and documents against the published page, and spoken words against the recording.
  • Quotes are verbatim, including the original spelling. Where only a reporter's paraphrase exists this is stated, and paraphrases are not placed in categories A, E or F.
  • Reposts are included only where the act of sharing is itself the point, and are labelled as reposts.
  • Mitigating statements, such as condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, are included for every councillor where found.
  • The absence of an item means none was found in this search, not that none exists.

The categories

  • A Meets an IHRA example Meets an IHRA example. Words that clearly fit a named example in the IHRA working definition of antisemitism. The example is stated on each item. Explicit comparisons of Israel, Israelis or Zionism with Nazism or the Holocaust, statements naming Jews, and classic antisemitic images used to describe Israel are placed here.
  • E Support for a proscribed organisation Support for a proscribed organisation. An express statement of support for an organisation proscribed under the Terrorism Act 2000, or praise of an attack on civilians. Each item states whether it was made before or after the organisation was proscribed. Palestine Action was proscribed on 5 July 2025; a further appeal is before the Supreme Court.
  • F Political affiliation Political affiliation. Membership of, candidacy for, or speaking at events of communist, Marxist-Leninist or revolutionary political groups. These are lawful affiliations and are recorded as facts.
  • B Criticism of Israel or related activism Criticism of Israel or related activism. Criticism of Israel or related activism that does not clearly fit an IHRA example. Claims about a "Zionist" or pro-Israel lobby, hostile statements about "Zionists" or Israelis rather than Jews, calls for a single state, statements about a right to resist, and opposition to a proscription without a statement of support are placed here.
  • C Statement on the motion Statement on the motion. Statements about, or formal support for, the motion.
  • D Context and mitigating statements Context and mitigating statements. Context and mitigating statements: condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, included for every councillor where found.

Fairness and the law

  • Category labels are this file's assessment against the IHRA examples, not findings of any authority.
  • Where a council has investigated a complaint about an item, the outcome is recorded with the item.
  • Claims that newspapers have retracted are not repeated in this edition.
  • Items concerning anyone who may face active criminal proceedings, or criminal allegations against third parties, are not included.
  • Each councillor with an item in category A or E is invited to respond before those items are published, and any response is added to their page.

Every item can be checked at its source. If anything here is wrong, or if you are the councillor and want to respond, write to hello@zionismisracism.co.uk: a correction goes up the day it is confirmed, and a response is added to the page in full.

Why Zionism is not racism

Cllr Kamel Hawwash's page on this site sets out what they put their name to and why it is wrong. The case, line by line, is on the main site: Is Zionism racism? and the motion, line by line.