These councillors say Zionism is racism
Racist

The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist. Why

← The evidence file

Cllr Mothin Ali

Evidence file

Green Party

Cllr Mothin Ali

Gipton and Harehills ward, Leeds City Council

Mothin Ali is a Green Party councillor for Gipton and Harehills ward on Leeds City Council. Mothin Ali has stated public support for the motion. This page records 31 items: 1 concerning support for a proscribed organisation; 16 concerning criticism of Israel or related activism; 3 concerning the motion; 11 of context or mitigating statements.

  • E Support for a proscribed organisation1Support for a proscribed organisation
  • B Criticism of Israel or related activism16Criticism of Israel or related activism
  • C Statement on the motion3Statement on the motion
  • D Context and mitigating statements11Context and mitigating statements

Their page: why they are wrongThe itemsHow this file was made

The items, in their own words

Each item gives the date, the platform, the words as published, the source, and a screenshot where one was taken. Category labels are this file's assessment, not findings of any authority. Items in categories A and E were put to the councillor before publication.

E Support for a proscribed organisation Support for a proscribed organisation 1

An express statement of support for an organisation proscribed under the Terrorism Act 2000, or praise of an attack on civilians. Each item states whether it was made before or after the organisation was proscribed. Palestine Action was proscribed on 5 July 2025; a further appeal is before the Supreme Court.

E Support for a proscribed organisation21 June 2025 · XVerified against the source

Before proscription of Palestine Action (lawful at the time)

I have had the pleasure of meeting many activists from Palestine Action. They're among the bravest, most decent members of our society, taking the action that our government is too weak and too immoral to take!

The decision to ban a protest group will impact ALL OUR FREEDOM!

If our society is to be truly free and democratic, people must be able to uphold their moral obligation to prevent killing, persecution, and genocide of other peoples. Terrorism is the indiscriminate killing of civilians, which is what the Israeli state is committing. While groups like @Pal_action have conversely arisen to prevent terrorism. The gross perversion of British law introduced under the Blair government must be redressed to allow good people to stand up for what's clearly right.

Only cowards fail to speak up time and time again in the face of a genocide, in the face of killings of children, mass starvation. When cowards fail, it leaves the matter to ordinary people.

Posted after reports that the government planned to proscribe Palestine Action and before the proscription took effect on 5 July 2025.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 21 June 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.

B Criticism of Israel or related activism Criticism of Israel or related activism 16

Criticism of Israel or related activism that does not clearly fit an IHRA example. Claims about a "Zionist" or pro-Israel lobby, hostile statements about "Zionists" or Israelis rather than Jews, calls for a single state, statements about a right to resist, and opposition to a proscription without a statement of support are placed here.

B Criticism of Israel or related activism16 June 2024 · XVerified against the source

A vote for labour is a vote for genocide People in Gaza are not having a happy Eid thanks to these genocide enablers This guy supported cutting off food water and electricity

Quote-post of Keir Starmer's Eid al-Adha message in June 2024.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 16 June 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism17 August 2024 · XVerified against the source

Once again Leeds showed up, calling for an end to genocide, an end to war crimes, an end to occupation. Every Saturday, Jews, Christians and Muslims walk hand in hand in peace. When there is justice and freedom for ALL will the world be a better place! #FreePalestine

Post with photos from a weekly Leeds march for Palestine, including a Greens for Palestine banner.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 17 August 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism8 September 2024 · XVerified against the source

We made history today, the first UK political party to officially recognise what's happening in Gaza as Genocide, what's happening in Palestine as Apartheid and continued support for BDS We made sure the party followed through on it's commitment made during the elections #GPC24

Post with a video from the September 2024 Green Party conference.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 8 September 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism31 October 2024 · XVerified against the source

No one should profit from Genocide, ethical investments include not profiting from fossil fuels, arms, human harm, the west Yorkshire pension fund needs to follow this example

@FossilFreeWYPF x.com/Pal_action/status/1851913733536137286

Quote-post of a Palestine Action post from an account that no longer exists, so its content is not visible, posted before proscription took effect on 5 July 2025, when sharing it was lawful.

Why this category: Endorses a Palestine Action post whose content is no longer visible; recorded as B.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 31 October 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism17 March 2025 · XVerified against the source

Israel is using SEXUAL VIOLENCE AS A WEAPON OF WAR! let that sink in

Quote-post of Ellie Chowns MP on a UN report into conduct in Gaza.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 17 March 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism7 October 2025 · XVerified against the source

We've called for the proscription of the IDF, we need sanctions now! @PSCupdates

Quote-post of a Palestine Solidarity Campaign post about the October 2025 Green Party conference, with a photo at the PSC stall.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 7 October 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism15 October 2026 · XVerified against the source

Making fake accusations of antisemitism as a shield to defend Israel’s atrocities damages the fight against antisemitism. This is the Labour right, still in charge. Disgusting.

Quote-post of a Zack Polanski post about antisemitism being used as a political issue.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 15 October 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism17 October 2026 · XVerified against the source

Solidarity with Sarah Helm and Sally Rooney. Standing up for peace and justice.

Quote-post of author Sarah Helm, who wrote: 'God help us authors who support Palestine and Palestine Action. Sounds like Adam would have all our books swept off the shelves in a jiffy.'

Source

Screenshot of the post, 17 October 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism24 February 2026 · X (replies)Verified against the source

This is exactly why you're called the genocide party! ... Anyway how much did you get? ... It looks like you need me to continue your education.

Replies to Labour MP David Taylor, which The Jewish Chronicle presented as alluding to payments from the Israel lobby.

Source

B Criticism of Israel or related activism7 October 2023 · XVerified against the source

White supremacist European settler colonialism must end!

Posted on the day of the Hamas attack on Israel; he later apologised for comments about the Gaza conflict.

Source

B Criticism of Israel or related activismafter 7 October 2023 · Not statedSecond-hand report

As reported, a paraphrase, not their words: defended the right of "indigenous people to fight back" after 7 October 2023.

Reported by The Jewish Chronicle on 2 September 2025, when he was elected Green Party deputy leader.

Source

B Criticism of Israel or related activismafter 7 October 2023 · VideoVerified against the source

They are not victims, they are occupiers, they are colonialists, they are European colonialists

Said of Israelis in a video after the 7 October 2023 attack, as quoted by The Jewish Chronicle.

Source

B Criticism of Israel or related activismabout April 2026 · Greens for Palestine meeting (reported by The Times)Verified against the source

We need to make sure that we are putting the party on notice straight away ... They're coming after more and more people.

Said at a Greens for Palestine meeting about members suspended over antisemitism complaints, whom he advised to get "serious legal advice".

Source

B Criticism of Israel or related activism3 May 2024 · VideoVerified against the source

We will not be silenced. We will raise the voice of Gaza. We will raise the voice of Palestine. Allahu akbar!

Filmed after his election as a Leeds councillor; the Green Party said it was investigating issues raised about him.

Source

B Criticism of Israel or related activismNovember 2025 · VideoVerified against the source

Any punitive measures that authorities take against him are discriminatory and they're targeting him for his activism.

Said in support of Bristol Green Cllr Abdul Malik, a magistrate who received a formal judicial warning for sharing a video of a Hamas press conference after 7 October 2023.

Source

B Criticism of Israel or related activismundated · YouTube (video)Verified against the source

So, that's why the Israeli lobby or the mega corporations, they have such an influence because...

From a YouTube conversation with Dr Sohail Hanif of the National Zakat Foundation; the Green Party said he was describing lobbying by foreign powers such as the Israeli government or large corporations.

Source Archive or report

C Statement on the motion Statement on the motion 3

Statements about, or formal support for, the motion.

C Statement on the motion14 October 2026 · XVerified against the source

Zack is right, and you’re a disgrace @AndyBurnham. The smears won’t work. Stop arming a genocide. Stop arresting pensioners for having more courage than you do.

Quote-post of Zack Polanski's reply to a Sky News report that Andy Burnham had ruled out a Labour-Green partnership over the motion.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 14 October 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
C Statement on the motion4 October 2026 · Middle East EyeVerified against the source

Zionism is an ethno-nationalist state. ... Zionism is resulting in ethnic cleansing ... The belief that one group of people is superior to another, I just can't accept that. ... In 2024 the Green Party recognised the genocide that was taking place in Gaza, before any other major political party.

Said as Green Party co-deputy leader at the conference that passed the "Zionism is Racism" motion.

Source

C Statement on the motion2026 · Green Party conference motion A105 (supporters list)Second-hand report

Name "Mothin Ali" appears in the printed supporters list.

A105 was the spring 2026 version of the "Zionism is Racism" motion; his name does not appear on the supporters list of the autumn version (E02) passed on 4 October 2026.

Source

D Context and mitigating statements Context and mitigating statements 11

Context and mitigating statements: condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, included for every councillor where found.

D Context and mitigating statements8 January 2025 · XVerified against the source

The workers party has never been a friend to British Muslims or Muslims anywhere, the proclamation by Galloway that 'the Arabs are a lost cause' shows, like most establishment politicians, he used British Muslims to gain political capital. Justice transcends political loyalties!

Quote-post of a 5Pillars report about remarks by the Workers Party deputy leader.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 8 January 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements11 August 2025 · XVerified against the source

I really appreciate this passionate endorsement from one of the co-founders of Jewish Greens, Ben Samuel @filosofical_140 When we build our alliances and realise that the bonds of unity are so much stronger than the divisions of hate! #heroofharehills #mothin4deputy #islandofbelonging

Post sharing a campaign video endorsement from a co-founder of Jewish Greens.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 11 August 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements2 October 2025 · XVerified against the source

My thoughts and prayers are with all those injured in today’s attack at a synagogue on Yom Kippur, and with the wider Jewish community who will be feeling deeply shaken. No one should feel unsafe in their place of worship. At moments like this, it’s important that we do not rush to conclusions or allow fear and division to take hold. Violence only fuels more violence - and we must all work to calm tensions, stand together, and reaffirm our shared commitment to peace and solidarity.

Post on the day of the attack at Heaton Park synagogue, Manchester, on Yom Kippur 2025.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 2 October 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements14 December 2025 · XVerified against the source

My heart goes out to the families of those affected in today's attack as well as the wider Jewish Community. At times like this it's important we stand in solidarity with our Jewish brothers and sisters.

Quote-post of Zack Polanski after an attack on a Chanukah event in Australia in December 2025.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 14 December 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements2 March 2026 · XVerified against the source

Someone shouted something near him therefore he's guilty' - that's a poor line of attack

If any of these journalists want a proper chat, my number isn't difficult to find

Quote-post of a post by Saul Staniforth about a Sky News segment reporting that slogans near him at an event included 'we must globalise resistance to US & zionist terrorism'; the slogans were not his words.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 2 March 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements12 March 2026 · XVerified against the source

Deeply concerned about this attack on a synagogue, what's worse is thete was a school attached. We must stand in solidarity with our Jewish brothers and sisters and work to heal the divides in our societies

Post sharing a Guardian report of a vehicle attack on a synagogue in Michigan.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 12 March 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements23 March 2026 · XVerified against the source

Volunteer organisations and charities provide a vital service to so many that the state and private sectors miss. That's why this antisemitic attack against Hatzola - a volunteer ambulance service is all the more abhorrent.

Post sharing a Guardian report of an arson attack on Hatzola ambulances in London.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 23 March 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements7 October 2026 · XVerified against the source

The loss of life on oct 7 and all the lives since, remains in our hearts and to be forever mourned. We must do everything in our power to protect humanity and remember each others value.

Quote-post of the Green Party's message on the third anniversary of 7 October.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 7 October 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements4 October 2026 · Middle East EyeVerified against the source

If Jewish members feel like they need an additional level of reassurance, then I think they're right to ask for that ... All members should feel safe in this party.

Said at the conference that passed the "Zionism is Racism" motion.

Source

D Context and mitigating statementsabout February 2026 · The Sunday Times (quoted in The Jewish Chronicle)Second-hand report

a plain-speaking Yorkshireman who calls it as it is ... Although the wording was clumsy, I will still call out anyone choosing to travel to join the IDF.

Comments to The Sunday Times, reported by The Jewish Chronicle on 5 February 2026, about his since-deleted video in which he called former Leeds University rabbi Zecharia Deutsch a "creep"; he did not withdraw his position.

Source

D Context and mitigating statementsMay 2024 · Public statementVerified against the source

sorry for any upset my comments caused about the Gaza conflict.

His apology after his posts of 7 October 2023 were reported following his election in May 2024.

Source

How this file was made

  • This file covers councillors listed on zionismisracism.co.uk as backing the motion passed at the Green Party conference on 4 October 2026. A councillor appears here only where at least one item about them meets the standards below.
  • Items come from the councillors' own public social media posts and videos, council records, election records, party websites and news reports, from 7 October 2023 onwards. Spoken words in videos were transcribed and checked against the recording.
  • Every item was checked against its source on 23 October 2026: social media posts against the live post or a screenshot of it, articles and documents against the published page, and spoken words against the recording.
  • Quotes are verbatim, including the original spelling. Where only a reporter's paraphrase exists this is stated, and paraphrases are not placed in categories A, E or F.
  • Reposts are included only where the act of sharing is itself the point, and are labelled as reposts.
  • Mitigating statements, such as condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, are included for every councillor where found.
  • The absence of an item means none was found in this search, not that none exists.

The categories

  • A Meets an IHRA example Meets an IHRA example. Words that clearly fit a named example in the IHRA working definition of antisemitism. The example is stated on each item. Explicit comparisons of Israel, Israelis or Zionism with Nazism or the Holocaust, statements naming Jews, and classic antisemitic images used to describe Israel are placed here.
  • E Support for a proscribed organisation Support for a proscribed organisation. An express statement of support for an organisation proscribed under the Terrorism Act 2000, or praise of an attack on civilians. Each item states whether it was made before or after the organisation was proscribed. Palestine Action was proscribed on 5 July 2025; a further appeal is before the Supreme Court.
  • F Political affiliation Political affiliation. Membership of, candidacy for, or speaking at events of communist, Marxist-Leninist or revolutionary political groups. These are lawful affiliations and are recorded as facts.
  • B Criticism of Israel or related activism Criticism of Israel or related activism. Criticism of Israel or related activism that does not clearly fit an IHRA example. Claims about a "Zionist" or pro-Israel lobby, hostile statements about "Zionists" or Israelis rather than Jews, calls for a single state, statements about a right to resist, and opposition to a proscription without a statement of support are placed here.
  • C Statement on the motion Statement on the motion. Statements about, or formal support for, the motion.
  • D Context and mitigating statements Context and mitigating statements. Context and mitigating statements: condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, included for every councillor where found.

Fairness and the law

  • Category labels are this file's assessment against the IHRA examples, not findings of any authority.
  • Where a council has investigated a complaint about an item, the outcome is recorded with the item.
  • Claims that newspapers have retracted are not repeated in this edition.
  • Items concerning anyone who may face active criminal proceedings, or criminal allegations against third parties, are not included.
  • Each councillor with an item in category A or E is invited to respond before those items are published, and any response is added to their page.

Every item can be checked at its source. If anything here is wrong, or if you are the councillor and want to respond, write to hello@zionismisracism.co.uk: a correction goes up the day it is confirmed, and a response is added to the page in full.

Why Zionism is not racism

Cllr Mothin Ali's page on this site sets out what they put their name to and why it is wrong. The case, line by line, is on the main site: Is Zionism racism? and the motion, line by line.