These councillors say Zionism is racism
Racist

The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist. Why

← The evidence file

Cllr Neil McEvoy

Evidence file

Propel

Cllr Neil McEvoy

Fairwater ward, Cardiff Council

Neil McEvoy is a Propel councillor for Fairwater ward on Cardiff Council. The campaign lists Neil McEvoy as backing the motion on the basis of an email; that email is not reproduced here. This page records 27 items: 2 assessed as meeting an IHRA example; 22 concerning criticism of Israel or related activism; 3 of context or mitigating statements.

  • A Meets an IHRA example2Meets an IHRA example
  • B Criticism of Israel or related activism22Criticism of Israel or related activism
  • D Context and mitigating statements3Context and mitigating statements

Their page: why they are wrongThe itemsHow this file was made

The items, in their own words

Each item gives the date, the platform, the words as published, the source, and a screenshot where one was taken. Category labels are this file's assessment, not findings of any authority. Items in categories A and E were put to the councillor before publication.

A Meets an IHRA example Meets an IHRA example 2

Words that clearly fit a named example in the IHRA working definition of antisemitism. The example is stated on each item. Explicit comparisons of Israel, Israelis or Zionism with Nazism or the Holocaust, statements naming Jews, and classic antisemitic images used to describe Israel are placed here.

A Meets an IHRA example13 January 2026 · XVerified against the source

IHRA example: using symbols and images associated with classic antisemitism to characterise Israel or Israelis ('chosen people' used pejoratively)

Al Jazeera. The chosen people Zionists are also attacking Christians. Enough examples.

Reply to a user asking for the source of a list of Palestinian babies killed; the phrase "the chosen people" is applied to Zionists.

Why this category: Uses 'the chosen people' derisively to characterise Zionists, a classic antisemitic image.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 13 January 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
A Meets an IHRA example27 September 2026 · XVerified against the source

IHRA example: drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis

I'm seeing a lot of Jewish people say that the Palestinians are treated in the same way as Jews were in 1930s & 1940s in Germany. The Zionists have their bots, but the world has seen their genocide in real time. Israel is a pariah state.

The comparison with 1930s and 1940s Germany is attributed to "a lot of Jewish people" and repeated in his own post.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 27 September 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.

B Criticism of Israel or related activism Criticism of Israel or related activism 22

Criticism of Israel or related activism that does not clearly fit an IHRA example. Claims about a "Zionist" or pro-Israel lobby, hostile statements about "Zionists" or Israelis rather than Jews, calls for a single state, statements about a right to resist, and opposition to a proscription without a statement of support are placed here.

B Criticism of Israel or related activism27 April 2024 · XVerified against the source

14,000 Palestinian children have been murdered since October 8th. 35 Israeli children died on October 7th; all murdered; some by Israelis under the Hannibal Doctrine. What a price. What silence. Zionism is not Judaism.

Standalone post from April 2024.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 27 April 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism26 June 2024 · Palestine Solidarity Campaign pledge list (Left Foot Forward)Verified against the source

Neil John McEvoy | Cardiff West | Propel

Listed among 2024 general election candidates who backed the Palestine Solidarity Campaign's six demands, which include an arms embargo on Israel and the right to boycott and divest.

Source

B Criticism of Israel or related activism3 October 2024 · XVerified against the source

It's a decades long dispute. Gaza is a concentration camp; violence will beget violence and so it will go on. It had to stop or the world will get roped in. Btw, the Zionist troops have routinely targeted Palestinian civilians for years and years, as well as peace activists like Rachel Corrie

Reply to a user; asked about the phrase, he replied in the same thread "How else would you describe Gaza?"

Why this category: Calls Gaza a 'concentration camp' without an explicit Nazi or Holocaust reference, recorded as B.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 3 October 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism19 October 2024 · XVerified against the source

What was 1948 when British soldiers were strung up & also blown up by European Zionists with no genetic link to the land they occupied? Freedom fighting? Terror?

Reply to the account @ShepherdWales in a discussion about Iran.

Why this category: Disputes the ancestral ties of 'European Zionists' to the land; recorded as B because it does not in terms deny a right to self-determination.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 19 October 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism20 October 2024 · XVerified against the source

Israel created Hamas & Hezbollah. Your leaders have suicidal ideation & you are dragging us all into your death wish. You didn't want to deal with secular voices, so fuelled radical Islam.

Reply to two other users, one of them Douglas Murray.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 20 October 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism24 October 2024 · XVerified against the source

The Israelis killed most of them. The Hannibal directive. Look it up.

Reply in a thread about the victims of the 7 October 2023 attack.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 24 October 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism28 October 2024 · XVerified against the source

I'm making enquiries about @cardiffcouncil pension funds and any possible connection to Zionist entities.

Standalone post about Cardiff Council pension funds.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 28 October 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism28 October 2024 · XVerified against the source

Definition of amnesia: everything that happened between 1940 and October 7th 2023 in Palestine.

Standalone post from October 2024.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 28 October 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism30 October 2024 · XVerified against the source

I am making enquiries about who @cardiffcouncil does business with now. I will be proposing that our City divests from any company supporting or profiting from the oppression of the Palestinian people.

Standalone post about Cardiff Council's business relationships and divestment.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 30 October 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism2 November 2024 · XVerified against the source

Stop arming Israel. Stop Israel funding UK politicians. They should act on our interests, not the Israeli Government's.

Quote-post of a post from an account that has since been suspended.

Why this category: A claim that Israel funds UK politicians, recorded as B under the lobby rule.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 2 November 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism9 November 2024 · XVerified against the source

Racist Israeli fans sparked a riot

Quote-post of a video clip about violence involving Maccabi Tel Aviv supporters in Amsterdam in November 2024.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 9 November 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism18 October 2025 · XVerified against the source

Israel should be banned

Reply in a thread with two other users; the post being replied to is not identified in the thread view, and in a follow-up he wrote that he opposes 'colonial settlers'.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 18 October 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism13 January 2026 · XVerified against the source

Israel is a fascist state

Reply to two other users.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 13 January 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism28 February 2026 · XVerified against the source

I'm a Wales first kind of person. Not Israel first; not a Zionist.

Reply to another user who had suggested he move to Palestine.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 28 February 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism28 February 2026 · XVerified against the source

Do you really think Hamas did it all alone? The first moment I saw it, I knew what was going on. Fools celebrated resistance. The players knew the cards.

Reply to a user who wrote that Hamas "did it to themselves" on 7 October.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 28 February 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism4 April 2026 · XVerified against the source

Add Epstein the Mossad asset. Israel is running Trump. It's a different kind of rogue state. Anti-Christian. Racist. Supremacists.

Reply in a thread on 4 April 2026 about Israel and the United States.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 4 April 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism17 May 2026 · XVerified against the source

Zionist supremacists are terrorists

Reply to two other users.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 17 May 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism23 May 2026 · InstagramVerified against the source

An Israeli missile a millisecond before the Zionists murdered brave people giving medical treatment. Not Hamas. Not terrorists. Medics. Israel has targeted children, civilians, medics schools, hospitals and journalists. Why did the Israeli Armed Forces stand down on October the 7th? Charlie Kirk asked the same; look what happened to him.

Instagram post with an image of a missile, also shared on X.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 23 May 2026, Instagram
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism24 May 2026 · XVerified against the source

There is so much evidence out there to evidence Zionist crimes. Palestinians are semites, unlike many Israeli colonialists with no genetic link to the region.

Reply in a thread; he posted the line "Palestinians are semites" on several other occasions in 2026.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 24 May 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism16 September 2026 · XVerified against the source

Who are the Nazis right now?

Reply to a user who posted an image about Macklemore dressing as an Orthodox Jew and giving a Nazi salute, after McEvoy had defended Macklemore; the post does not say who is meant.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 16 September 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism24 September 2026 · XVerified against the source

They were European terrorists. They displaced the indigenous population. What happened was extreme. There is no place for Christians in greater Israel either. The European élite controlling the US again through Israel, was an interesting take on matters I heard recently.

Reply in a thread about 1948 and the founding of Israel.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 24 September 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism8 October 2026 · XVerified against the source

Palestinians are semites. Zionist anti-semitism is a huge issue.

Reply to a Reform UK Wales video of Helen Jenner MS saying Jewish people do not feel safe in Britain.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 8 October 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.

D Context and mitigating statements Context and mitigating statements 3

Context and mitigating statements: condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, included for every councillor where found.

D Context and mitigating statements24 February 2024 · XVerified against the source

Disagree with @cardiffcouncil supporting a side in a war, when they should provide services politically neutral. No side taken on Palestine/Israel/Yemen, or other wars. A Projection for Peace is far more appropriate.

Quote-post of a Cardiff Council post about lighting Cardiff Castle in support of Ukraine.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 24 February 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements23 October 2024 · XVerified against the source

Never in any single post will you see any support for Hamas. Trust me on that one.

Reply to a user who had accused him of supporting Hamas.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 23 October 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements21 October 2025 · XVerified against the source

Dehumanise Palestinians. For the record, you will see no record anywhere of me supporting barbarism on either side. Israel seed funded Hamas; Hamas enabled ethnic cleansing. Was there a stand down order, as Charlie Kirk asked?

Reply to a user who had tagged him asking for comment.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 21 October 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.

How this file was made

  • This file covers councillors listed on zionismisracism.co.uk as backing the motion passed at the Green Party conference on 4 October 2026. A councillor appears here only where at least one item about them meets the standards below.
  • Items come from the councillors' own public social media posts and videos, council records, election records, party websites and news reports, from 7 October 2023 onwards. Spoken words in videos were transcribed and checked against the recording.
  • Every item was checked against its source on 23 October 2026: social media posts against the live post or a screenshot of it, articles and documents against the published page, and spoken words against the recording.
  • Quotes are verbatim, including the original spelling. Where only a reporter's paraphrase exists this is stated, and paraphrases are not placed in categories A, E or F.
  • Reposts are included only where the act of sharing is itself the point, and are labelled as reposts.
  • Mitigating statements, such as condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, are included for every councillor where found.
  • The absence of an item means none was found in this search, not that none exists.

The categories

  • A Meets an IHRA example Meets an IHRA example. Words that clearly fit a named example in the IHRA working definition of antisemitism. The example is stated on each item. Explicit comparisons of Israel, Israelis or Zionism with Nazism or the Holocaust, statements naming Jews, and classic antisemitic images used to describe Israel are placed here.
  • E Support for a proscribed organisation Support for a proscribed organisation. An express statement of support for an organisation proscribed under the Terrorism Act 2000, or praise of an attack on civilians. Each item states whether it was made before or after the organisation was proscribed. Palestine Action was proscribed on 5 July 2025; a further appeal is before the Supreme Court.
  • F Political affiliation Political affiliation. Membership of, candidacy for, or speaking at events of communist, Marxist-Leninist or revolutionary political groups. These are lawful affiliations and are recorded as facts.
  • B Criticism of Israel or related activism Criticism of Israel or related activism. Criticism of Israel or related activism that does not clearly fit an IHRA example. Claims about a "Zionist" or pro-Israel lobby, hostile statements about "Zionists" or Israelis rather than Jews, calls for a single state, statements about a right to resist, and opposition to a proscription without a statement of support are placed here.
  • C Statement on the motion Statement on the motion. Statements about, or formal support for, the motion.
  • D Context and mitigating statements Context and mitigating statements. Context and mitigating statements: condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, included for every councillor where found.

Fairness and the law

  • Category labels are this file's assessment against the IHRA examples, not findings of any authority.
  • Where a council has investigated a complaint about an item, the outcome is recorded with the item.
  • Claims that newspapers have retracted are not repeated in this edition.
  • Items concerning anyone who may face active criminal proceedings, or criminal allegations against third parties, are not included.
  • Each councillor with an item in category A or E is invited to respond before those items are published, and any response is added to their page.

Every item can be checked at its source. If anything here is wrong, or if you are the councillor and want to respond, write to hello@zionismisracism.co.uk: a correction goes up the day it is confirmed, and a response is added to the page in full.

Why Zionism is not racism

Cllr Neil McEvoy's page on this site sets out what they put their name to and why it is wrong. The case, line by line, is on the main site: Is Zionism racism? and the motion, line by line.