These councillors say Zionism is racism
Racist

The Green Party's "Zionism is Racism" motion is racist: it brands most British Jews racists."Zionism is Racism" is racist. Why

← The evidence file

Cllr Shabir Fazal

Evidence file

Green Party

Cllr Shabir Fazal

Central ward, Hyndburn Borough Council

Shabir Fazal is a Green Party councillor for Central ward on Hyndburn Borough Council. Shabir Fazal has stated public support for the motion and signed the open letter of 19 October 2026 by Green councillors supporting it. This page records 17 items: 13 concerning criticism of Israel or related activism; 2 concerning the motion; 2 of context or mitigating statements.

  • B Criticism of Israel or related activism13Criticism of Israel or related activism
  • C Statement on the motion2Statement on the motion
  • D Context and mitigating statements2Context and mitigating statements

Their page: why they are wrongThe itemsHow this file was made

The items, in their own words

Each item gives the date, the platform, the words as published, the source, and a screenshot where one was taken. Category labels are this file's assessment, not findings of any authority.

B Criticism of Israel or related activism Criticism of Israel or related activism 13

Criticism of Israel or related activism that does not clearly fit an IHRA example. Claims about a "Zionist" or pro-Israel lobby, hostile statements about "Zionists" or Israelis rather than Jews, calls for a single state, statements about a right to resist, and opposition to a proscription without a statement of support are placed here.

B Criticism of Israel or related activism31 July 2025 · XVerified against the source

Starmer always was and always will be a zionist asset, a corrupt and flawed politician. He lies by habit, he has no principles and sold his soul to the zionists, billionaires, arms companies years ago. He is an embarrassment.

Reply to Ellie Chowns MP and Muslim Greens.

Why this category: Lobby-control language ('zionist asset', 'sold his soul to the zionists'), recorded as B under the lobby rule.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 31 July 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism2 August 2025 · XVerified against the source

We expect abuse from racists, fascists, zionists and islamaphobes - it shows we are on the right side - the side of justice, equality and decency. @MothinAli is and always will be on the right side of history. #mothin4deputy @muslim_greens @Greens4P

Reply in a thread supporting Mothin Ali's campaign for Green Party deputy leader.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 2 August 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism5 August 2025 · XVerified against the source

These sick zionists bast*rds have no filters. They've got so used to saying and doing whatever they want ,( including genocide and war crimes) without consequences that they think it is their right. @KernowDamo @muslim_greens @Greens4P @MothinAli

Quote-post of a post by Alan MacLeod that was itself quoting a post comparing the President of Ireland to a film character.

Why this category: A hostile generalisation about Zionists, recorded as B.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 5 August 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism10 August 2025 · XVerified against the source

Yes @PhilipProudfoot - Labour is a death cult and Starmer is a deaf cu*t! Deaf to genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity, ethnic cleansing and apartheid. However, his deafness is selective, he hears every command from his Israeli pimps. @MothinAli @owenjonesjourno

Quote-post of a Philip Proudfoot post describing Labour as a 'death cult', tagging Mothin Ali and Owen Jones.

Why this category: Claims the Prime Minister takes 'command[s]' from 'Israeli pimps', recorded as B under the lobby rule.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 10 August 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism11 August 2025 · XVerified against the source

@AbubakerAbedW The BBC has been captured by the pro- Israel lobbies supported by billionaires and corrupt politicians. Journalism at the Beeb is dead, now it's all propaganda. Perfect reply. FREE FREE PALESTINE @MothinAli @muslim_greens @kennardmatt @Greens4P @owenjonesjourno

Quote-post of a journalist who said he had refused a BBC interview and called the BBC 'a mouthpiece for Zionism'.

Why this category: Claims the BBC is 'captured' by pro-Israel lobbies, recorded as B under the lobby rule.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 11 August 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism11 August 2025 · XVerified against the source

Anyone who still believes it all started on 7th Oct is a liar, a zionist or a corrupt genocide supporting politician. This is genocide, ethnic cleansing, annihilation. No one can say they don't know. Choose which side of history you are on. @MothinAli @muslim_greens @Greens4P

Quote-post of a post about the Al Jazeera journalist Anas Al Sharif, killed in Gaza in August 2025.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 11 August 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism16 August 2025 · XVerified against the source

That's right, Israel murdered a baby. Not the first, not the last - they will keep on killing babies and children, it's what they do. Over 15,000 and rising. Some they blow up, some they shoot and some they starve to death with Starmer's support #StarmerOut @MothinAli @Greens4P

Quote-post of a post reporting the death of a baby in Gaza.

Why this category: Refers to Israel's conduct in Gaza; recorded as B because it is framed as describing state actions.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 16 August 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism19 August 2025 · XVerified against the source

This is not about terror4sm - everyone, including all the corrupt politicians like Yvette Cooper owned by the Israel lobby, knows that Pal Act*on are not terrorist. Its a show of power. It's a way of trying to quell the huge support for Palestine. #StarmerOutNow #FreePalaestine

Posted on 19 August 2025, after Palestine Action's proscription took effect on 5 July 2025; it states Palestine Action are 'not terrorist' without stating support for the group.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 19 August 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism21 August 2025 · XVerified against the source

This is what happens when Israelis are allowed to commit unconscionable crimes without any consequences. They take this sense of immunity with them wherever they go. They hate Christians

Quote-post of a Shaun King post that is now unavailable; the words generalise about Israelis rather than Jews.

Why this category: A generalisation about Israelis, not Jews, recorded as B.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 21 August 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism23 August 2025 · XVerified against the source

Well done Liverpool - always leading the fight against the racists, fascists and zionists.

Reply to a post by Alan Gibbons headed 'Liverpool is anti fascist'.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 23 August 2025, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism15 October 2026 · XVerified against the source

The Greens will not support any Labour Council's who support the Isra4li genocide, enable war crimes or agree to selling weapons t the genocidal regime.

Reply to Sky News journalist Sam Coates during the October 2026 row over the Green Party motion.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 15 October 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism15 October 2026 · XVerified against the source

Utter bullshit - only two sides here and neither of them is Jewish or Muslim. You are either on the right side of history or you are an apologist for or complicit in the zionist, colonial genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity.
@MothinAli @Greens4P @muslim_greens

Reply to Gary Spedding's post on the Green Party "Zionism is racism" motion dispute.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 15 October 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
B Criticism of Israel or related activism21 October 2026 · XVerified against the source

@Geri_E_L_Scott Israel and US' unprovoked lethal attack on a sovereign nation murdered its leader, his family and grandchildren. They also bombed a primary school killing 160 children. Your double standards are staggering. @Greens4P @KernowDamo @TheGreenParty @owenjonesjourno

Reply to a journalist's post about the Green Party motion, referring to the US and Israeli strike on Iran.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 21 October 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.

C Statement on the motion Statement on the motion 2

Statements about, or formal support for, the motion.

C Statement on the motion19 October 2026 · Open letter of Green councillorsSecond-hand report

We are Green councillors who support the "Zionism is Racism" motion passed at the Green Party conference on 4th October 2026. ... We reject the conflation of Zionism with Jewish people, and we oppose antisemitism alongside other forms of injustice

Collective open letter, listed as signatory 35, "Cllr Shabir Fazal OBE, Central, Hyndburn Council", as reproduced on a campaign website.

Source

C Statement on the motion14 October 2026 · XVerified against the source

@Peston the Labour Party is complicit in the genocide. The supplied and continue to supply the weapons used to murder innocent Palestinian babies and children. The Greens will not form an alliance with war criminals! @MothinAli @KernowDamo @Greens4P @muslim_greens @kennardmatt

Reply to Robert Peston after the Prime Minister described the Green Party 'Zionism is racism' motion as antisemitic.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 14 October 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.

D Context and mitigating statements Context and mitigating statements 2

Context and mitigating statements: condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, included for every councillor where found.

D Context and mitigating statements7 August 2024 · XVerified against the source

Which white person was arrested for saying Hamas are terrorists? Hamas are a proscribed organisation and by definition are described by Police and Government as terrorists. Trying to win an argument by making totally made up and false stories is typical of far right narratives

Reply in a thread under a Sky News post, stating that Hamas is a proscribed organisation.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 7 August 2024, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.
D Context and mitigating statements12 October 2026 · XVerified against the source

Well done @muslim_greens and Jewish Greens. Racism is abhorrent but forv5je @Telegraph it's in their blood.

Reply praising a joint statement by Muslim Greens and Jewish Greens.

Source

Screenshot of the post, 12 October 2026, X
Screenshot, taken 23 October 2026. Opens at full size.

How this file was made

  • This file covers councillors listed on zionismisracism.co.uk as backing the motion passed at the Green Party conference on 4 October 2026. A councillor appears here only where at least one item about them meets the standards below.
  • Items come from the councillors' own public social media posts and videos, council records, election records, party websites and news reports, from 7 October 2023 onwards. Spoken words in videos were transcribed and checked against the recording.
  • Every item was checked against its source on 23 October 2026: social media posts against the live post or a screenshot of it, articles and documents against the published page, and spoken words against the recording.
  • Quotes are verbatim, including the original spelling. Where only a reporter's paraphrase exists this is stated, and paraphrases are not placed in categories A, E or F.
  • Reposts are included only where the act of sharing is itself the point, and are labelled as reposts.
  • Mitigating statements, such as condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, are included for every councillor where found.
  • The absence of an item means none was found in this search, not that none exists.

The categories

  • A Meets an IHRA example Meets an IHRA example. Words that clearly fit a named example in the IHRA working definition of antisemitism. The example is stated on each item. Explicit comparisons of Israel, Israelis or Zionism with Nazism or the Holocaust, statements naming Jews, and classic antisemitic images used to describe Israel are placed here.
  • E Support for a proscribed organisation Support for a proscribed organisation. An express statement of support for an organisation proscribed under the Terrorism Act 2000, or praise of an attack on civilians. Each item states whether it was made before or after the organisation was proscribed. Palestine Action was proscribed on 5 July 2025; a further appeal is before the Supreme Court.
  • F Political affiliation Political affiliation. Membership of, candidacy for, or speaking at events of communist, Marxist-Leninist or revolutionary political groups. These are lawful affiliations and are recorded as facts.
  • B Criticism of Israel or related activism Criticism of Israel or related activism. Criticism of Israel or related activism that does not clearly fit an IHRA example. Claims about a "Zionist" or pro-Israel lobby, hostile statements about "Zionists" or Israelis rather than Jews, calls for a single state, statements about a right to resist, and opposition to a proscription without a statement of support are placed here.
  • C Statement on the motion Statement on the motion. Statements about, or formal support for, the motion.
  • D Context and mitigating statements Context and mitigating statements. Context and mitigating statements: condemnations of antisemitism or of Hamas, apologies and withdrawals of support, included for every councillor where found.

Fairness and the law

  • Category labels are this file's assessment against the IHRA examples, not findings of any authority.
  • Where a council has investigated a complaint about an item, the outcome is recorded with the item.
  • Claims that newspapers have retracted are not repeated in this edition.
  • Items concerning anyone who may face active criminal proceedings, or criminal allegations against third parties, are not included.
  • Each councillor with an item in category A or E is invited to respond before those items are published, and any response is added to their page.

Every item can be checked at its source. If anything here is wrong, or if you are the councillor and want to respond, write to hello@zionismisracism.co.uk: a correction goes up the day it is confirmed, and a response is added to the page in full.

Why Zionism is not racism

Cllr Shabir Fazal's page on this site sets out what they put their name to and why it is wrong. The case, line by line, is on the main site: Is Zionism racism? and the motion, line by line.